The Edmond Sun

Business

June 8, 2012

Public workers in fiscal, political bull's eye

This has been a difficult year for government workers across the country, who are fighting uphill battles to hang on to their pensions and stable salaries — and it's not over yet.

From California to Pennsylvania, workers are facing efforts to sharply curtail the job security and benefits they have enjoyed for years, perks long viewed as compensation for the sometimes lower salaries in the public sector.

Now, the perks that came with being a firefighter or a teacher have become a target, not only for conservative lawmakers but for Democrats under pressure to make deep cuts in government budgets.

Experts note a marked loss of public support for government workers and their powerful unions, a sentiment shared by conservative activists eager to weaken organized labor. And never have they been more confident than this week, when Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, R, fended off a recall attempt orchestrated largely by unions outraged at his efforts to end collective bargaining for most public employees and teachers.

"We absolutely intend to use this going forward," said Brendan Steinhauser, spokesman for FreedomWorks, a tea party organization that has been working to undercut public employee unions' power through state legislatures. The group views the failed attempt to unseat Walker as a powerful motivator for other Republican governors.

The message, Steinhauser said, is: "Be bold, be a leader, be a conservative and you'll be rewarded."

Wisconsin is one of several places where public employees have become targets this year. In California, San Diego and San Jose residents voted overwhelmingly Tuesday to cut pension benefits for city workers. The votes followed dramatic steps to curb union power in Indiana and Louisiana, and efforts by some in Congress to freeze salaries and whittle away benefits for federal workers.

Lawmakers in Pennsylvania and elsewhere are considering legislation that would weaken teachers unions. And some conservatives plan to push Republican leaders in Michigan, where lawmakers have had limited success curbing union power, to redouble their efforts after Walker's victory next door.

Public workers have also borne much of the brunt of job cutting in recent years. Since June 2008, state and local governments have shed more than 500,000 jobs. And while the private sector has experienced some recovery, public-sector job losses continue to mount.

Karen McDonough, who has worked in the city of San Jose's environmental services department for two decades, said before Tuesday's vote she tried to change voters' minds by telling them her version of the story: that she is a hard-working senior employee who had gone years without a pay raise.

"The response I got the most was 'I don't get a pension. Why should you?' " McDonough said in an interview Thursday. "I tried to explain to them that [the pension] is part of our total compensation, that we don't get stock options and bonuses. We're just different. That is not something they're interested in hearing anymore."

Public employee unions, which became the heart of the labor movement with the decline of manufacturing unions, have lost the public relations battle, experts say. Once viewed as middle-class stalwarts who labor for the common good, government workers now are often seen as unwilling to make the same sacrifices as their counterparts in the private sector.

"I think that it's the fault of the unions themselves for failing to recognize they are out of step with the public sympathies," said Gary Chaison, a professor of labor relations at Clark University in Massachusetts. "There is a perception that, through their political influence, they are getting a special deal. They're doing well while others are not."

Union officials contend that the public is not aware of the sacrifices government employees have made. Federal workers' pay rates, for example, have been frozen for the past two years — although raises for individuals still are allowed for promotions and some other reasons — and most new employees hired starting next year will contribute a greater proportion of their salary to retirement benefits.

On the state level, they say, public employees are being attacked and scapegoated by organized labor's political foes. Some union officials agree that they are partly to blame for the unfriendly atmosphere — that over the years, as the percentage of Americans belonging to unions has declined, they have not done enough to convey the important role unions play in the community. But they also note that in many of the battles they've fought and lost, including the one in Wisconsin, they were vastly outspent by their opponents.

"It's clearly going to have some impact when you have the relentless attacks like we've seen," said Steve Smith, a spokesman for the California Labor Federation. "But at the end of the day these are firefighters, teachers, police officers, neighbors, local heroes."

In San Diego and San Jose, voters overwhelmingly supported measures to reduce pension plans for city employees. In San Jose, with the Democratic mayor's support, 70 percent of voters backed the plan. Proponents said the measures would bring their pensions in line with earners in private industry.

That tide has swept the country, led by Republican governors. This year, Gov. Mitch Daniels signed a bill establishing Indiana as the nation's 23rd "right to work" state, which prevents unions from charging nonunion members mandatory dues. In Louisiana, Gov. Bobby Jindal pushed through a series of bills targeting teacher tenure and salaries. The next battle may unfold in Michigan, where union backers are vowing to enshrine collective-bargaining rights in the state constitution.

Some Democratic leaders also have been butting heads with their public employee unions. Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel has called for a suspension of the automatic cost-of-living increases granted to retirees, and Illinois Gov. Pat Quinn is seeking to cut the pensions of current state workers.

In Pennsylvania, advocates of school vouchers are fighting a pitched battle with teachers unions. The conservative activists behind the push say it is a two-pronged effort to bring about a policy change while delivering a blow to the unions.

Text Only
Business
  • screenshot tumblr.jpg VIDEO: Tumblr sold to Yahoo! for $1.1 billion

    Yahoo! has purchased Tumblr for $1.1 billion, hoping to compete more effectively with sites like Google and Facebook.

    May 20, 2013 1 Photo

  • g0002580000000000009c9c9aeaf90cd173258b5b3ca558d2786396b3a1.jpg Kia Optima is a hit with the buying public

    When it comes to midsized family sedans, the Kia Optima ranks high on my list for its good looks, economy and value.

    May 20, 2013 1 Photo

  • AT&T provides 5,000 career opportunities for veterans

    AT&T is stepping up its veteran recruiting efforts with the goal of hiring 5,000 veterans and their family members into career opportunities during the next five years, consistent with its commitment to equal employment opportunities.

    May 17, 2013

  • Frontier Country Marketing Association, Edmond CVB win tourism industry awards

    Frontier Country Marketing Association and several of its members were honored May 6 at the annual RedBud Awards Ceremony during National Tourism Week, May 4-12. Lt. Gov. Todd Lamb and “Discover Oklahoma” host Jenifer Reynolds presented the prestigious awards to the tourism industry at the Oklahoma History Center in Oklahoma City.

    May 17, 2013

  • Citizens Bank presents Small Business Week networking event

    Citizens Bank of Edmond is supporting the Edmond Area Chamber of Commerce’s Small Business Week with a networking event scheduled for 4:30-6 p.m. Thursday at Citizens Bank of Edmond, 1 E. First St.

    May 17, 2013

  • FAPC wine project adding value to Oklahoma wines

    A project conducted at Oklahoma State University’s Robert M. Kerr Food & Agricultural Products Center aims to strengthen the quality of Oklahoma wines and help increase overall wine sales throughout the state.

    May 17, 2013

  • Public relations firm hires former News 9 journalist

    After spending countless hours covering breaking news, former television reporter Jacqueline Sit, of Edmond, is taking her journalism skills to serve as account executive for Oklahoma-based Candor Public Relations.

    May 13, 2013

  • Arvest Bank promotes 4

    Arvest Bank has announced the promotions of Gary Myles, Jarom Christie, Brent Sartin and Amanda Gillespie. Myles has been promoted to vice president, Christie and Sartin to assistant vice president and Gillespie to branch manager.

    May 13, 2013

  • The Backyard Farmer opens at Shoppes at Northpark

    In its 40th year, the Shoppes at Northpark welcomes Galt Ormiston’s Backyard Famer Stand, a traditional Oklahoman produce stand specializing in fresh locally grown foods. With more than 20 years experience, Galt is a gardening expert offering advice in custom design, installation and maintenance.

    May 13, 2013

  • Steve's Rib Steve’s Ribs grabs the silver ring

    Steve’s Ribs owners just celebrated their silver anniversary with a new menu and extended summer hours.

    May 13, 2013 1 Photo

Stocks