The Edmond Sun

Letters to the Editor

July 12, 2013

LETTER: Reader disputes columnist’s energy logic

EDMOND — To the Editor:

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I try to consider this as I read the Guest Opinion, published in Saturday’s issue, written by Lt. Col. Steve Russell (“Eco-warriors use unsound logic,” July 6, 2013, The Edmond Sun). He states that wind-powered electrical generators are but “an abysmal eye sore,” and laughs off its current percentage of total energy production. His disdain of what he calls “eco-warriors” and their advocacy of renewable energy systems is obvious. Therefore should I assume he sees beauty in coal mines and coal powered plants surrounded by giant piles of black, spewing poisons into the air? Maybe his eye beholds the beauty of an oil refinery, or one of many oil spills, such as the recent one caused by a train derailment destroying a small town in Quebec and killing multiple people. But he must really have to squint to see the beauty of a massive open pit tar sands mine, such as the ones in Alberta, that will supply the Keystone pipeline he advocates.

To me, efficiency is beauty; like a wind-powered generator producing electricity cleanly and safely. The new generation of solar collectors, most developed by China and Japan, produce electricity with no moving parts or waste: Now that’s beautiful.

He incorrectly asserts that “unsound logic” is used by clean energy proponents. Yet he uses unsound logic when comparing wind generated power to crude and tar sand oil. One directly produces electricity and the other produces fuel primarily to power our motor vehicles. The Keystone XL pipeline will have zero effect on the price and availability of electricity. Fact is, the world is developing and converting our motor vehicles to run on electricity; no one is converting our home air conditioners and lights to run on oil. Electricity produced by wind and solar is the future. Oil as a source of power is found mainly in the halls of government where money from big oil and energy companies is the only thing keeping this dying source alive.

If we Americans are really serious about our vulnerability to foreign oil supplies, we would take the most effective course of action; drastically reduce our consumption of oil. This course is never mentioned by Lt. Col. Russell. Instead he uses the same old misleading statements used for decades by the oil, gas, coal and nuclear industries. They degrade anyone who using sound logic and facts to offer alternates to those sources of energy.

Speaking of facts, the average “energy returned on investment,” or EROI, for conventional oil is 25:1. For tar sands oil this ratio is 2.9:1, meaning one unit of natural gas is required to create less than 3 units of energy. Some estimate that the ratio is closer to 1:1, when transportation, environmental costs and end use efficiency is taken into account. So energy from tar sands is only efficient if you make money from its production.

The lieutenant colonel is free to use any logic he chooses to behold beauty in anything he sees. In the meantime the rest of the world will see the beauty of sound logic, based on facts, to inspire the transition to renewable clean domestic sources of energy, all while drastically reducing the number of our soldiers sent into harm’s way to defend foreign energy sources.

 

Danny Smith

Edmond

1
Text Only
Letters to the Editor
  • LETTERS: Covell grocery store proposal needs careful consideration

    I’m writing to you today because I was just stuck in traffic at the flooded intersection of Covell and Coltrane. I’m worried about the proposed development of a potential Wal-Mart on the northwest corner of this intersection. This is a 24-hour, 42,000-square-foot, big-box discount store and gas station.

    July 19, 2014

  • LETTER: Train whistle disrupts sweet slumber

    To the Editor:
    I’ve lived in Edmond since 1971 and have always heard the trains. Okay, there is a track so that makes sense. They were never a problem before the past six months. However, things change and so have they. I am older than before so I expected my hearing to be less, not better.

    June 17, 2014

  • LETTER: Local family thanks Jerry’s Automotive

    I recently moved to the City of Edmond and like most people when you move you look for certain things: grocery stores, parks, golf courses. But what I most was looking for — something important to me and my 20-month-old son — was a mechanic. I own a classic Jeep and for more than a year I’ve jumped from shop to shop hoping that someone could make the right recommendations or diagnosis to make the car safe for my family.

    May 28, 2014

  • LETTER: State Alzheimer’s plan needs update

    There are more than 5 million Americans living with Alzheimer’s disease with 60,000 in Oklahoma. My father passed away from the disease three years ago after a long courageous battle.  With all the stress and strain of caregiving my mom had to visit the doctor’s office more often. These are but two of the reasons I am proud to work for the Alzheimer’s Association.

    May 27, 2014

  • Why Oklahoma should keep the Common Core

    May 20, 2014

  • Letter carriers’ food drive needs your support

    To the Editor:
    Help your letter carrier “Stamp Out Hunger” by leaving a plastic bag filled with canned food donations by your mailbox today. In Edmond, donations benefit the Regional Food Bank of Oklahoma’s partner agencies HOPE Center of Edmond and Route 66 Project. This effort is part of the 22nd annual Letter Carriers’ Food Drive, which is the largest one-day food drive in America.

    May 9, 2014

  • Death penalty not the answer

    To the Editor:
    On April 29 Oklahoma is scheduled to execute two of its citizens by lethal injection, a fact that saddens me very much. The crimes that these two men were convicted of committing were horrific and my heart goes out to the victims and their families.
    However, I agree with those who feel that Oklahoma is very much in the wrong when the state comes to hiding fundamental facts about its plans for lethal injection from the public.

    April 28, 2014

  • Congress needs to help Veterans

    To the Editor:
    Whoever we send to Congress should devote more attention to the ways Washington is failing its veterans and military families. (“Jolley says Oklahoma common sense needed in Congress,” April 21, 2014, The Edmond Sun) Vets must wait for months for a response to their disability claims, due to longstanding delays at the VA. And nearly a quarter of young veterans are unemployed.

    April 28, 2014

  • Secrecy regarding lethal injection uncalled for

    To the Editor:
    I agree with those who feel that Oklahoma is very much in the wrong when it comes to hiding basic facts about its plans for lethal injection from the public.
    It’s important to remember that concern about the way the state carries out executions is not the same thing as sympathy for the condemned. If we are to have good government, it is essential for us to be able to fully know, understand and be able to communicate with our government about its actions.

    April 28, 2014

  • An open letter to motorists in Oklahoma

    To the Editor:
    The Oklahoma Legislature has once again given its blessing to texting and driving. By not passing one of the many bills filed this year that would have made the practice illegal, the Legislature is in effect saying, “Want to text and drive in Oklahoma? No problem.”
    Although lawmakers have two more months left in the current session, texting ban bills have been given their last rites.

    April 4, 2014