The Edmond Sun

Local News

November 1, 2012

Federal judge mulls Hobby Lobby injunction request

OKLAHOMA CITY — An attorney said he expects Hobby Lobby to prevail in its lawsuit seeking to preserve the Green family’s rights to carry out its mission free from government coercion.

On Sept. 12, Hobby Lobby, a Christian-owned and operated arts and crafts retailer, filed suit seeking a preliminary injunction, an exemption from a rule in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act that requires businesses with more than 50 employees to cover what the company calls “abortion-inducing” drugs. About 93 percent of businesses with 50-199 employees already offer coverage, according to the Obama administration.

The Affordable Care Act requires coverage of contraceptives including the birth control pill; intrauterine devices; and emergency contraceptives, aka the “morning-after pill,” which is taken within a few hours or days of sexual intercourse. The ACA does not require coverage of RU-486, aka “the abortion pill,” which causes an abortion when taken in the first few weeks of pregnancy. The “morning-after pill” prevents fertilization or ovulation, and may disrupt implantation of a fertilized egg.

A total of 38 cases representing hospitals, universities, businesses, schools and individuals have been filed over the federal “rule,” according to The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty.

Thursday morning, Kyle Duncan, general counsel for the Becket Fund, and Department of Justice attorney Michelle Bennett argued before Judge Joe Heaton during a two-hour hearing in U.S. District Court, Western District of Oklahoma.

Heaton said the case covers some “treacherous terrain” in “uncharted territory.” It raises some new and difficult problems, he said. Attorneys also spent time discussing the free exercise of religion relating to individuals versus businesses and the First Amendment.  

After quizzing the attorneys on issues including the threat of irreparable harm and if an injunction would adversely affect the public interest, Heaton said he would render a decision on a preliminary injunction as promptly as possible given time issues.

Fines for businesses with more than 50 employees not participating in the required coverage begin Jan. 1. Hobby Lobby says it could face fines of up to $1.3 million a day, $26 million a year.

Founded by David Green in 1970, Oklahoma City-based Hobby Lobby operates 524 stores with more than 13,000 full-time employees. The Green family operates Mardel, a chain of Christian bookstores, and Hobby Lobby through a management trust.

The Greens run the businesses according to their Christian faith, Duncan said. In its purpose statement the owners declare they are committed to “honoring the Lord in all we do by operating the company in a manner consistent with Biblical principles.” The family believes it is by God’s grace that Hobby Lobby has endured and prospered.

The plaintiffs maintain that levying fines on someone for following their faith is wrong, alien to American traditions of individual liberty, religious tolerance and limited government. The concept also violates federal law and the U.S. Constitution, they argue.

Because of their beliefs about unborn human life, their prescription coverage excludes contraceptive devices that can cause abortion such as IUDs and pregnancy terminating drugs, namely the “morning after pill” and the “week after pill,” Duncan said.

The issue is not about access to contraception but who pays for it, Duncan said.

The Green family cannot in good conscience knowingly offer coverage for abortion-causing drugs or devices, Duncan said. Because they are a for-profit business they are not covered by the religious employer exemption, Duncan said. And its health insurance plans are not “grandfathered” under the Affordable Care Act.

Bennett argued partially along Obama administration lines. The administration states that scientists have abundant evidence that birth control has significant health benefits for women and their families, is documented to significantly reduce health costs and is the most commonly taken drug in America by young and middle-aged women.

“Plaintiffs’ challenge rests largely on the theory that a for-profit, secular corporation established to sell art and craft supplies can claim to exercise religion and thereby avoid the reach of laws designed to regulate commercial activity. This cannot be,” the government stated in its response.

The government cited United States V. Lee, in which the Supreme Court recognized that “when followers of a particular sect enter into commercial activity as a matter of choice, the limits they accept on their own conduct as a matter of conscience and faith are not to be superimposed on the statutory schemes which are binding in others in that activity.”

Hobby Lobby has been planning for the 2013 insurance plan year, a complex and time-consuming process, the plaintiffs stated in their petition. The approaching mandate casts grave uncertainty on their ability to provide insurance for thousands of employees and their families in January, they contend. A lapse in coverage would be disastrous for the businesses and for the employees and their families who depend on the company’s insurance, the plaintiffs argue.

marks@edmondsun.com | 341-2121, ext. 108

1
Text Only
Local News
  • jc_OUChuck Spicer.jpg OU Medical Center expands with new ER

    OU Medical Center Edmond is expanding its services. A new freestanding OU Medical Center Emergency Department will be built at the Veranda Shopping Center, Lisa Wilson, CEO of OU Medical Center Edmond, announced Thursday.
    The emergency department will be located just outside the border of the City of Edmond at Northwest 150th Street and Western. Construction costs are estimated at $5.5 million.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Nick and Karen 2.JPG Massey speaks to Summit Rotary

    Council member Nick Massey, standing here with Edmond Sun Publisher Karan Ediger, spoke to Summit Rotary Tuesday on the subject of the City’s electronic sign laws. Summit Rotary Club meets at 7 a.m. Tuesdays at Oklahoma Christian University, 2501 E. Memorial Drive. For more
    information about the club, call 405-CUEARLY.

    April 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • Keep these tips in mind for May gardening

    Here are a few things to keep in mind as you head into your May gardening routine. Keep ahead of the weeds. We are always happy for the rain, but wet ground can keep us out of the garden and that allows weeds to grow by leaps and bounds. Now is the time to guard tender plants such as tomatoes, eggplant and peppers against sudden late frosts. During the first part of May you may be planting beans, early corn, okra and late potatoes. You also may be replacing tomato plants lost to late frosts. Finish setting out cabbage, lettuce, cauliflower, beets, etc.
    Here are some things to do:

    April 24, 2014

  • Jurors hear evidence in mercy killing murder trial

    Testimony is underway in the trial of a Logan County man accused of murdering his wife by placing a plastic sack over her head and causing her to suffocate.
    On June 13, 2013, Logan County District Attorney Tom Lee filed a first-degree murder charge against Mark Schemm, 53, of Crescent, who told an OSBI agent in court records he killed Monica Schemm, his wife, because she asked him to kill her.

    April 24, 2014

  • Man faces civil suit in motorcycle fatality

    A local man awaiting disposition of a criminal charge stemming from the death of an Edmond motorcyclist now faces a civil suit, court records show.
    On Sept. 24, 2013, Edmond Police Officer Milo Box was dispatched on a call regarding a collision at the Santa Fe-Country Wood Lane intersection, according to the report filed by Box.
    Box stated Daniel Bricker, 54, of Deer Creek, was traveling northbound in the inside lane of Santa Fe while Erron Heise, 39, the motorcycle driver, was stopped and waiting to turn left onto Country Wood Lane.

    April 24, 2014

  • Sheriffs accuse state of ducking out on prisoner promises

    State efforts to save time and money by shuffling prisoners more swiftly through the system are riling local sheriffs who are losing money because of the efficiency program.
    A change in Department of Corrections practice is landing a “significant hit” on two-thirds of Oklahoma counties, which depend on reimbursements to house state inmates locally, said Ken McNair, executive vice president of the Oklahoma Sheriffs’ Association.
    “The sheriffs are now in a position where they have to make adjustments to their budgets,” he said.
    Sheriffs converged on the Capitol on Tuesday, filling the Senate gallery, in part to protest efforts to remove inmates from their custody. The change will cost the sheriffs — but save the state — millions each year.

    April 24, 2014

  • OK officials account for disaster spending

    Nearly a year after deadly tornadoes hit central Oklahoma, officials announced that they have spent close to $9.4 million in private donations on relief efforts.

    April 24, 2014

  • north 1.jpg U.S. News ranks city high schools in state’s Top 10

    All three Edmond high schools are ranked among the Top 10 in the state in a prestigious national list.
    U.S. News & World Report, which publishes annual rankings, ranked Edmond North No. 3 in Oklahoma and No. 437 nationwide. Memorial ranked No. 6 in Oklahoma and No. 847 nationwide. Santa Fe ranked No. 8 in Oklahoma and No. 1,075 nationwide.
    “This recognition serves as validation for our students, parents and staff members at all levels who work together relentlessly in pursuit of academic excellence, Edmond Public Schools Superintendent David Goin said.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • OC expands to 5 academic colleges

    Oklahoma Christian University will expand from three to five colleges beginning with the 2014-15 academic year.
    OC’s five academic colleges will be the College of Biblical Studies, the College of Business Administration, the College of Engineering and Computer Science, the College of Liberal Arts and the College of Natural and Health Sciences.
    “Our academic and leadership teams have been planning, praying and discussing how to build on OC’s legacy of exceptional success in science, engineering and business,” said Scott LaMascus, vice president for academic affairs. “Our new colleges will focus on growth in these areas and implement strategic planning to help us serve more students.”

    April 23, 2014

  • N Front Door 3.jpg FBI seeks suspect in robbery of local bank

    Police and FBI agents are investigating the robbery of a local bank by a suspect wearing a fake mustache and goatee, a spokesman said.
    FBI Special Agent Martinus McConnell said the robbery occurred Tuesday morning at the Arvest Bank, 2025 Sonoma Park, Edmond.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

Featured Ads
NDN Video
Poll

Do you agree with a state budget proposal that takes some funds away from road and bridge projects to ramp up education funding by $29.85 million per year until schools are receiving $600 million more a year than they are now? In years in which 1 percent revenue growth does not occur in the general fund, the transfer would not take place.

Agree
Disagree
Undecided
     View Results