The Edmond Sun

Local News

November 1, 2012

Federal judge mulls Hobby Lobby injunction request

OKLAHOMA CITY — An attorney said he expects Hobby Lobby to prevail in its lawsuit seeking to preserve the Green family’s rights to carry out its mission free from government coercion.

On Sept. 12, Hobby Lobby, a Christian-owned and operated arts and crafts retailer, filed suit seeking a preliminary injunction, an exemption from a rule in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act that requires businesses with more than 50 employees to cover what the company calls “abortion-inducing” drugs. About 93 percent of businesses with 50-199 employees already offer coverage, according to the Obama administration.

The Affordable Care Act requires coverage of contraceptives including the birth control pill; intrauterine devices; and emergency contraceptives, aka the “morning-after pill,” which is taken within a few hours or days of sexual intercourse. The ACA does not require coverage of RU-486, aka “the abortion pill,” which causes an abortion when taken in the first few weeks of pregnancy. The “morning-after pill” prevents fertilization or ovulation, and may disrupt implantation of a fertilized egg.

A total of 38 cases representing hospitals, universities, businesses, schools and individuals have been filed over the federal “rule,” according to The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty.

Thursday morning, Kyle Duncan, general counsel for the Becket Fund, and Department of Justice attorney Michelle Bennett argued before Judge Joe Heaton during a two-hour hearing in U.S. District Court, Western District of Oklahoma.

Heaton said the case covers some “treacherous terrain” in “uncharted territory.” It raises some new and difficult problems, he said. Attorneys also spent time discussing the free exercise of religion relating to individuals versus businesses and the First Amendment.  

After quizzing the attorneys on issues including the threat of irreparable harm and if an injunction would adversely affect the public interest, Heaton said he would render a decision on a preliminary injunction as promptly as possible given time issues.

Fines for businesses with more than 50 employees not participating in the required coverage begin Jan. 1. Hobby Lobby says it could face fines of up to $1.3 million a day, $26 million a year.

Founded by David Green in 1970, Oklahoma City-based Hobby Lobby operates 524 stores with more than 13,000 full-time employees. The Green family operates Mardel, a chain of Christian bookstores, and Hobby Lobby through a management trust.

The Greens run the businesses according to their Christian faith, Duncan said. In its purpose statement the owners declare they are committed to “honoring the Lord in all we do by operating the company in a manner consistent with Biblical principles.” The family believes it is by God’s grace that Hobby Lobby has endured and prospered.

The plaintiffs maintain that levying fines on someone for following their faith is wrong, alien to American traditions of individual liberty, religious tolerance and limited government. The concept also violates federal law and the U.S. Constitution, they argue.

Because of their beliefs about unborn human life, their prescription coverage excludes contraceptive devices that can cause abortion such as IUDs and pregnancy terminating drugs, namely the “morning after pill” and the “week after pill,” Duncan said.

The issue is not about access to contraception but who pays for it, Duncan said.

The Green family cannot in good conscience knowingly offer coverage for abortion-causing drugs or devices, Duncan said. Because they are a for-profit business they are not covered by the religious employer exemption, Duncan said. And its health insurance plans are not “grandfathered” under the Affordable Care Act.

Bennett argued partially along Obama administration lines. The administration states that scientists have abundant evidence that birth control has significant health benefits for women and their families, is documented to significantly reduce health costs and is the most commonly taken drug in America by young and middle-aged women.

“Plaintiffs’ challenge rests largely on the theory that a for-profit, secular corporation established to sell art and craft supplies can claim to exercise religion and thereby avoid the reach of laws designed to regulate commercial activity. This cannot be,” the government stated in its response.

The government cited United States V. Lee, in which the Supreme Court recognized that “when followers of a particular sect enter into commercial activity as a matter of choice, the limits they accept on their own conduct as a matter of conscience and faith are not to be superimposed on the statutory schemes which are binding in others in that activity.”

Hobby Lobby has been planning for the 2013 insurance plan year, a complex and time-consuming process, the plaintiffs stated in their petition. The approaching mandate casts grave uncertainty on their ability to provide insurance for thousands of employees and their families in January, they contend. A lapse in coverage would be disastrous for the businesses and for the employees and their families who depend on the company’s insurance, the plaintiffs argue.

marks@edmondsun.com | 341-2121, ext. 108

1
Text Only
Local News
  • MS_prisons 1.JPG DOC action could save $36.8 million annually

    The Oklahoma Department of Corrections expects to avert more than 2,100 offenders by 2021 saving more than $36.8 million annually, an audit states.
    Tuesday, State Auditor and Inspector Gary Jones  released the results of a performance audit of the DOC that was requested by Gov. Mary Fallin. The audit for the period July 1, 2007 through June 30, 2013, distinctly focused on governance, financial management and capacity management.
    Audit recommendations included:

    July 30, 2014 2 Photos

  • food bank.jpg Regional Food Bank receives donation

    At a special celebration event Wednesday, Walmart and the Walmart Foundation announced that over the last fiscal year they gave more than $30 million in cash and in-kind contributions to charitable organizations throughout Oklahoma. Additionally, the retailer and its Foundation have partnered with local food banks to provide more than 15 million pounds of food to residents.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • Man allegedly assaults officer on Tinker AFB

    A metro man faces an assault complaint after he allegedly nearly struck a federal officer with a vehicle during a pursuit that began as a traffic stop on Tinker Air Force Base, court records show.
    Sanford C. Coats, U.S. attorney for the Western District of Oklahoma, said Wednesday a criminal complaint was unsealed charging James Williams, 60, of Del City, with assaulting a federal officer with a dangerous weapon.

    July 30, 2014

  • NAMI classes begin in September

    NAMI Edmond North-OKC, the local organization of the National Alliance on Mental Illness, will offer its Family-to-Family Education Program beginning Sept. 2. It will contine Sept. 4 and 8-9. Classes will be at Crossings Community Church, Quail Springs United Methodist Church, Francis Tuttle Technology Center (Portland campus), Tinker AFB Chapel and the Thunderbird Club House in Norman.
    NAMI Family-to-Family is a free 12-session education program for family caregivers of adults living with mental illness. The sessions are offered once a week for a few hours each.

    July 30, 2014

  • drugs 1.jpg K9 hot on drug trail

    An Oklahoma County deputy and his K9 partner have logged another impressive drug seizure, records show.
    Oklahoma County Sheriff’s Office spokesman Mark Myers said Monday a deputy noticed a car weaving and straddling lanes on I-40 near the Meridian Avenue exit. Myers said the deputy stopped the vehicle and spoke with the two people inside.
    The driver and passenger told conflicting stories about their trip, Myers said. The deputy also smelled marijuana inside of the vehicle, Myers said.

    July 30, 2014 3 Photos

  • City spends $1.7 million on ITS

    Public safety will benefit by the Intelligent Transportation System with its implementation by the City of Edmond, said Steve Commons, assistant city manager.
    More vehicles are added to traffic volume as Edmond’s population grows. ITS connects all of the city’s traffic signals in order to improve traffic flow in present time with greater efficiency, Commons said Wednesday.
    “Some of that can be done through computer automation that tracks how traffic is changing,” Commons said.

    July 30, 2014

  • clinic 1.jpg Edmond church to host free eye clinic

    An Edmond church and Feed the Children are partnering to provide a free eye clinic.
    Individuals will be able to receive a free vision test and free prescription eye glasses from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Aug. 9 at the Waterloo Road Baptist Church, 3100 E. Waterloo Road. All ages are welcome and registration is not required.

    July 29, 2014 2 Photos

  • weather 1.jpg July could be coolest in weather record books

    With chances for soaking rains and unseasonably cool temperatures becoming frequent, a weather expert is increasingly convinced Oklahoma will end up with a historic July.
    At mid-afternoon Tuesday, the National Weather Service forecast for Edmond called for the high Wednesday to be near 73 with a 90 percent chance of heavy rain, followed by the high Thursday near 78 with a 30 percent chance of showers.
    Highs are expected to remain in the 80s into Monday.

    July 29, 2014 3 Photos

  • Downtown Master Plan accepted by council

    The 2014 Downtown Master Plan Study was accepted by a 3-0 vote Tuesday evening by the Edmond City Council.
    Fort Worth-based consulting group Freese and Nichols presented their final update to the 1998 Downtown Master Plan. The city hired the group at a cost of $300,000 to make recommendations for future development of Broadway in the central business district.
    “There are clearly some short-term (parking) options that we feel should move forward,” said Cody Richardson, of Freese and Nichols consultants of Fort Worth. “Better signage at existing parking lots.”

    July 29, 2014

  • UCO forensic volunteer wants to aid more agencies

    A four-person group of forensic investigators who volunteer their time to help smaller Oklahoma police departments isn’t enough to meet demand, a member said.
    Kama King, who recently completed her graduate research and will be a member of the faculty at the University of Central Oklahoma’s Forensic Science Institute, said outside of full-time jobs, members of the group volunteer to assist these agencies.
    As her career progresses, King hopes to help establish a permanently funded organization available to any agency in the state to assist in remains recovery as well as related training.

    July 29, 2014

Featured Ads
NDN Video
Heartwarming 'Batkid Begins' Documentary is Tear-Jerker Orlando Bloom 'Takes a Swing' at Justin Bieber In Ibiza Pitch Invading Morons Cause Chaos - @TheBuzzeronFOX Sadie Doesn't Want Her Brother to Grow Up "Maxim" Hotness! See Jessica Alba's Sizzling Spread Two women barely avoid being hit by train Broken Water Main Floods UCLA Orlando Bloom and Justin Bieber Reportedly Came To Blows In Ibiza Meet the Man Behind Dumb Starbucks Chris Pratt Adorably Surprises Kids at a 'Guardians of the Galaxy' Screening NOW TRENDING: Peyton Manning dancing at practice "The Bachelorette" Makes Her Decision Thieves pick the wrong gas station to rob Golden Sisters on '50 Shades' trailer: 'Look At That Chest!' Staten Island Man's Emotional Dunk Over NYPD Car - @TheBuzzeronFOX GMA: Dog passes out from excitment to see owner Baseball Hall of Famers Inducted 'Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1' Sneak Peek Florida Keys Webcam Captures Turtles Hatching Morgan Freeman Sucks Down Helium on 'Tonight Show'
Poll

The runoff race for the 5th District congressional seat is set for Aug. 26. If the voting were today, which candidate would you support?

Al McAffrey
Tom Guild
Undecided
     View Results