EDITOR’S NOTE: Part I of this story appeared in Tuesday’s edition of The Sun.
The City Council rejected recommendations by the 2010 Sign Ordinance Review Committee at a public workshop this week. Whether the City of Edmond will permit businesses to use electronic message center signage remains in the dark for the foreseeable future.
Revising the current ordinance would have allowed an expanded commercial use of EMC without businesses having to request a variance.
Three former mayors — Saundra Naifeh, Randel Shadid and Dan O’Neil — spoke against updating the current sign ordinance.
“You have an ordinance in place and the digital sign is not part of what Edmond has approved in its ordinances,” Naifeh said. “In fact you made a choice to grant a variance.”
Individual reasons already have taken into account for EMC variances already approved by the council, Naifeh said.
City Councilman Nick Massey told The Edmond Sun that he is disappointed that the council could not work toward a compromise position with regard to electronic message center signage.
“Edmond is a thriving modern community and it is time to move Edmond into the 21st century with modern day signage,” Massey said. “When done properly and tastefully, having EMC signage does not diminish quality of life in Edmond and in fact makes us a more modern city.”
The current sign ordinance defines three corridors to allow larger square footage and taller signs up to 25 feet in height and 77 square feet. These corridors are on Broadway, Second Street going east to Interstate 35, West Edmond Road and 33rd Street from Broadway to Boulevard, said Bob Schiermeyer, city planner. Ground signs include monument signs, he added.
The committee’s recommendations included:
• EMC allowed only on ground signs, no EMC wall signs.
• EMC allowed on signs that fully comply with all current standards in the code, these include height, square footage, side yard setback, landscaping, pole cover and all other structural requirements. This will prohibit non-conforming signs from being converted to EMC signs.
• A 30-second static text message with a transition of two seconds between messages. All products offered must be sold on the property, no off-premises advertising.
• No more than 50 percent of the maximum square footage of the sign allowed will be EMC signs.
• Daytime NITS: 6,500; Nighttime NITS: 500. NITS shall be certified by an engineer for the permit.
Non-conforming signs adapted to EMC standards would continue to be non-conforming signs, Mayor Charles Lamb said. The LED lighting would be increased during the daytime and could be made dimmer at night, said Jim Gleason of Superior Neon Signs.
“Most of my clients probably favor electronic signs. I do not, never have, never will,” said Shadid, an attorney who represents business interests before the council. Shadid helped to craft the current sign ordinance during his two terms as mayor from 1991-95.
“I just think they’re traffic hazards; they’re eyesores,” Shadid said. “People tell you it enhances business. I do not believe that. I oppose the clutter, the distraction of electronic signs.”
O’Neil said the I-35 corridor will be Edmond’s downtown for the next century. Care is needed in developing it, he added. People will shop here because Edmond has quality standards, O’Neil said.
“We’re not very good about regulating things after the fact. It just doesn’t happen,” O’Neil said. “Whose going to be the NIT guard of the NIT police.”
Someone with a business plan and love for a business in their own town will make their business work for them,” said Naifeh, former owner of a gift shop.
“I think what you’re talking about instead of a sign ordinance is an advertising ordinance,” Naifeh said. “Let’s be really clear — this is about advertising and the amount of messages that we would like to put out to the public.”
If clutter and safety is a problem with EMC, they would be already be banned everywhere, said Justin Booher of Vital Signs of Edmond.
“I think what we need to do is find a happy medium, a balance between residential and commercial,” Booher said.
Businesses don’t want the time-consuming effort of inserting big letters on outdated signs, said businessman Dave Thomas, owner of Thomas Supply Center. His sign is getting old, he said. Thomas can spend $10,000 updating his existing sign that is based on 1950s technology or wait for the city to join 21st century with modern signage, he said.
“My advantage is I could sit safely at my desk even if it’s raining outside,” Thomas said. “… I could safely change the sign to whatever we have for sale that day.”
Edmond resident Ronnie Williams said Edmond is a unique place. Looking like every other town with a “video canyon” would be contrary to maintaining the quality of life that residents expect of Edmond, Williams said.
“The last thing I want to do is live somewhere where I drive through a canyon of lights,” Williams said.
Massey said the council’s lack of decision making is detrimental to business and economic development. Instead of now having a workable ordinance that everyone can live with, businesses must continue bringing their variance requests, one at a time, before the city council.
“This is time consuming and will create even more confusion and lack of continuity. I hope we will find a way to consider this again in the future,” Massey said.
Lamb said he favors preparing the language of an EMC ordinance for the council to approve or not.
“I’m not willing to deal with changes,” Lamb said. “But, I’m at the point in saying that it seems to me we need to draw up whatever rules we’re comfortable with and go from that point.”
Lamb directed city staff to look into hiring a special consultant to address EMC and provide information for the council to consider a “dark sky ordinance” in town. The consultancy would also provide information for I-35 sign standards.
“I am especially concerned about the clutter, especially when you throw in the graphics, not just the letters,” said Elizabeth Waner, city councilwoman.
Light is a concern as well the possibility of having EMC signs create clutter by allowing them every 25 feet, Waner said. Long-term maintenance of the signs could be a problem, she said. An unleveled playing field would result if some businesses don’t have the money to afford the signs, Waner said.
“I think it is going to be a headache for the community to enforce,” Waner said. The city would have to monitor the EMC within 48 hours of placement, she said.
City Councilman Darrell Davis agreed with Waner that enforcing EMC codes would be costly and problematic. More information is needed about the impact of light illumination creep in Edmond, he said. Lamb said maintaining dark skies is especially important east of I-35.
“I understand from a business perspective the need, the desire,” Davis said. “I’m looking at it from a city perspective, the things we have to deal with.”
Massey agreed with O’Neil that churches should be omitted from EMC use. It would not be fair for churches outside areas zoned for EMC not to be able to benefit from a new ordinance, he said.
“I do think though that five to eight seconds, or 12 seconds, is too fast,” Massey said of pauses before light display would change.
City Councilwoman said she would be comfortable if EMC would be limited to once-a-day changes. Changing the ordinance would permit every business on Broadway the eventual use of EMC lighting, she said.
“I’m also uncomfortable with graphics,” Caldwell said. “… If I can see a gallon of milk with price, then I can also see boxer shorts with price, mainly on a model or something. I don’t want to have to figure out a way to monitor that.”
firstname.lastname@example.org | 341-2121
EDITOR’S NOTE: Part I of this story appeared in Tuesday’s edition of The Sun.
- Local News
Helping those who are overlooked
With a projected cost of $4.2 million for a new Men’s Center at the City Rescue Mission, Edmond Memorial High School students are hoping they can raise enough money to complete the project.
The student-led Swine Week goal is $375,000 for Memorial’s annual fundraiser, which ends March 14.
Each year for the past 28 years, Memorial students have taken to the streets, completed dares, held assemblies, silent auctions, custom car shows and contacted businesses and residents in order to raise mounder way.
“Whenever the City Rescue Mission presented to the Student Council we saw how they help families and we realized that if we ever have to find a place to stay there is one,” Ball said. “If we meet our goal we realize that we will impact the honey for Swine Week.
Eye doctor appeals city-imposed reverse office parking
The City of Edmond may need to step up its method of educating motorists who should be parking in a reverse angle in front of Dr. Brad Fielding's optometry office at 13 N. University Drive, said Nick Massey, city councilman. Massey has talked to a few people who are unhappy about the Bicycle Master Plan’s reverse angle parking the city implemented at Fielding’s office, he said. He thought the reverse parking plan was a dumb idea when he first learned about it.
Ex-fire official loses legal battle
An ex-fire official has lost his effort to get his job back after being fired due to allegations of gun play reported by a city employee.
Experts urge residents to change smoke alarm batteries
Changing batteries in smoke and carbon monoxide alarms may rate pretty low on the exciting things to do scale, but it’s a simple act that can save lives.
Tank removal clears way for auxiliary project
Removal of a 10,000-gallon fuel storage tank takes the city one step closer toward construction of a new Edmond Police Department secondary work site.
Mid-day Friday, Oklahoma Environmental Services removed an underground tank from city-owned property located just west of the railroad tracks off 33rd Street. When the site is fully prepared, work will begin on a 15,000-square-foot structure that will house Edmond Police Department evidence and lab work and related functions.
Crime victims must re-register for notifications from Pardon and Parole Board
Attorney General Scott Pruitt Friday issued a consumer alert for crime victims to re-register for notices after data in a Pardon and Parole Board notification system was corrupted.
Downtown Library to close for new carpeting
The Downtown Library, 300 Park Ave., will be closed to the public from March 31 through April 27 for new carpet installation.
Warren graduates from basic infantry training
Army National Guard Pvt. Alec L. Warren has graduated from basic infantry training at Fort Benning, Columbus, Ga. During the nine weeks of training, the soldier received training in drill and ceremonies, weapons, map reading, tactics, military courtesy, military justice, physical fitness, first aid and Army history, core values and traditions
Register for Youth Forestry Camp
Oklahoma Forestry Services is offering teens the opportunity to learn more about the forest while exploring Oklahoma’s natural resources in beautiful Beavers Bend State Park at its 58th Annual Youth Forestry Camp
Nonprofit, tribal, community and faith-focused grant writing seminar
The Citizen Potawatomi Tribe is presenting a seminar on grant writing geared toward nonprofit agencies, tribes, municipalities, schools, libraries and faith-based organizations.
- More Local News Headlines
- Helping those who are overlooked