The Edmond Sun

Oklahoma State House

December 21, 2013

Income-tax ruling may send lawmakers back to start

Ada — Lawmakers will have to figure out a new way to reduce state income taxes and finance improvements at the Capitol complex after the Oklahoma Supreme Court struck down a bill that would have accomplished those goals, Rep. Todd Thomsen said Friday.

“I think there was an attempt to do something wise and planned out, but they balked at having two different subjects combined in one issue,” the Ada Republican said. “So we’ll have to address that.”

Last week, the Supreme Court tossed out a law from the 2013 legislative session that called for incremental cuts in the state income tax, tied to economic growth.

The court ruled that House Bill 2032 was unconstitutional because it also contained language setting up a fund to pay for repairs to the state Capitol building. The state Constitution bars lawmakers from combining two unrelated subjects in a single bill.

HB 2032 called for reducing Oklahoma’s top income tax rate from 5.25 percent to 5 percent on Jan. 1, 2015. Under the bill, the top rate would have dropped to 4.85 percent in 2016 if state revenues equaled or surpassed the fiscal impact of that tax cut.

The bill included provisions establishing a fund for Capitol building repairs, starting with a $60 million allocation in fiscal year 2014, which began last July 1. The state would have earmarked another $60 million for repairs in fiscal year 2015.

The state Supreme Court ruled that HB 2032 violated the single-subject rule, which was designed to prevent a practice known as logrolling. The practice combines two subjects in a single bill — in this case, tax cuts and repairs to the Capitol — forcing lawmakers to approve an unpopular bill along with a popular one.

“Taxation policy and the appropriation of state funds for Capitol improvements are not germane, relative or cognate to a readily apparent common theme and purpose,” Justice James Winchester wrote for the unanimous court. “A voter could certainly be for one measure and not the other but forced to approve the entire bill in order to pass the desired legislation. The single subject rule prohibits this unpalatable choice.”

The ruling will send lawmakers back to the drawing board if they decide to tackle both issues again in 2014. Gov. Mary Fallin was noncommittal last week about whether her budget proposal for next year will include income-tax cuts after receiving predictions that the Legislature will have $170.8 million less to spend in 2014.

Thomsen said that tax cuts are a perennial hot topic in the Legislature. He predicted that lawmakers will take up the issue again in 2014, but he added that they will have to balance the prospect of tax relief against the need to fund essential services.

“I think we also have to be cautious and be wise so we also take care of state functions,” he said.

State Sen. Susan Paddack, D-Ada, said it was difficult to predict whether lawmakers would consider tax cuts again in 2014.

“I am hopeful that lawmakers will be very cautious about further tax cuts, in light of the fact that we’re already $170 million down,” she said.

EDITOR’S NOTE: The Oklahoman contributed to this report.

Reach Eric Swanson at adanewsreporter@cableone.net.

1
Text Only
Oklahoma State House
  • History_Tour_5_BH.jpg History tours begin May 17

    Downtown Enid will be the scene of Chisholm Trail Coalition Walking Tours

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Candidate filing period ends

    From the U.S. Congress to the Oklahoma House, several incumbents are hoping to hold onto their jobs in the 2014 elections.

    April 15, 2014

  • Wheel Chair UCO community develops $200 wheelchair prototype

    Last month, the Congressional Research Service reported that a total of 1,558 soldiers who served in Afghanistan and Iraq endured major limb amputations due to battlefield injuries. They include the loss of one or more limbs, the loss of one or more partial limbs or the loss of one or more full or partial hand or foot.

    April 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • 4-9 Disc Golf-signing.jpg Pros give local disc golfer a special birthday

    Chances are local member of the Chickasha Disc Golf Club Emily Beach will long remember her 15th birthday.

    April 9, 2014 1 Photo

  • Former Oklahoma Supreme Court Justice Hargrave built legacy

    Former Oklahoma Supreme Court Justice Rudolph Hargrave died Tuesday in Ada. He was 89.
    A graveside service is set for 2 p.m. Friday at Oakwood Cemetery in Wewoka, with the Rev. Susan Rice presiding, according to Stout-Phillips Funeral Home in Wewoka.

    April 2, 2014

  • Speedy Dog reunited with family after missing 2 years

    “Speedy” the Chihuahua was reunited with his family after a 26-month stint around the metro area. His owners, Lori and Don Whitton, said if he had not been micro chipped, he would not be home right now. The Whittons urge pet owners get ...

    April 2, 2014 1 Photo

  • Pianist to perform with Enid Symphony April 5-6

    March 29, 2014

  • 6049_1_0028.jpg Wind $$$: More than $1 billion from industry

    The study found the state’s 26 operational wind farms added more than 1,600 full-time jobs to Oklahoma’s economy. They pay more than $22 million per year in royalties to landowners.

    March 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • Authorities searching for Ada man

    Authorities from several agencies continue to search for a 38-year-old Ada man missing since March 10.
    “The Pontotoc County Sheriff’s Office, Ada Police Department, along with assistance from the Chickasaw Nation Lighthorse Police Department are currently attempting to determine the location of missing person, Charles Dewayne Manuel,” Sheriff John Christian said Wednesday. “Manuel left his grandparent’s home in Ada on March 10 and the family had no contact with him since that time. Manuel was officially reported missing on March 17.”

    March 26, 2014

  • Oklahoma teachers might be required to prepare for new standards

       For the past three years, Ada City Schools officials have drawn up curriculum maps, trained teachers and taken other steps to implement the Common Core academic standards.

    March 26, 2014