The Edmond Sun

Opinion

June 28, 2012

The Columbus (Ga.) Ledger-Enquirer: Affordable Care decision: Politics and precedent

EDMOND — Thursday’s U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding the key provisions of the Affordable Care Act is a landmark ruling by any reasonable definition of that familiar term.

Such status does not in itself convey value judgment: “Landmark” cases have ranged from the reprehensible Dred Scott ruling of 1857 to the civil rights affirmation of Brown v. Board of Education in 1954; somewhere in between are still hotly debated outcomes like Roe v. Wade in 1973 or Bush v. Gore in 2000.

But the high court’s narrow (to the surprise of few) ruling will serve as a new precedent for congressional authority. Indeed, despite the public and political identification of the health care act with President Obama, the ruling has larger implications for the legislative branch of government than for the executive.

The immediate political bounce is a judicial vindication and political victory for the president: The Affordable Care Act is a centerpiece of his agenda. Long term, it will be part of his record and legacy — for better or worse.

The politics between now and November might be tougher to handicap. Polls have consistently shown a majority generally opposing the health care mandates, and an even larger majority insisting that some kind of health care reform is imperative.

If the justices have been influenced by political rhetoric about the law — and in an ideal but imaginary world they would not be — then attempts by opponents to portray the insurance mandate as “the largest tax increase in American history” might have backfired. (Every tax, at every level of government, is invariably portrayed by opponents as the largest in history, so that tack has perhaps lost some of its political sting.)

If it is indeed a tax, then it is within the constitutional authority of Congress to approve it: “Because the Constitution permits such a tax,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the majority, “it is not our role to forbid it, or to pass upon its wisdom or fairness.”

The corollary, of course, is that if Congress has the authority to approve such a law, then it is also within the power of this or a future Congress to amend it, improve upon it or discard it. It has survived a legal challenge; if it survives future political ones, then health care law in the U.S. is subject to fine tuning, which can be a good thing. When tens of millions of Americans have no affordable access to health care short of the emergency room, politicians might be well advised to tread lightly.

The law’s ultimate test will not be political, but practical: its real-life impact on the millions of Americans it affects — its benefits, its costs, and whether the balance between the two is reasonable and sustainable. The status quo cannot be an option.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Bangladesh’s sweatshops — a boycott is not the answer

    One year ago this week, the eight-story Rana Plaza garment factory collapsed in Bangladesh’s capital city of Dhaka, killing 1,129 people. The building’s top floors had been added illegally, and their weight caused the lower stories to buckle. Many of the victims were young women who had been sewing low-priced clothes for Western brands, earning a minimum wage of about $9 a week. It was the worst disaster in garment industry history.

    April 24, 2014

  • Loosening constraints on campaign donations and spending doesn’t destroy democracy

    Campaign finance reformers are worried about the future. They contend that two Supreme Court rulings — the McCutcheon decision in March and the 2010 Citizens United decision — will magnify inequality in U.S. politics.
    In both cases, the court majority relaxed constraints on how money can be spent on or donated to political campaigns. By allowing more private money to flow to campaigns, the critics maintain, the court has allowed the rich an unfair advantage in shaping political outcomes and made “one dollar, one vote” (in one formulation) the measure of our corrupted democracy.
    This argument misses the mark for at least four reasons.

    April 23, 2014

  • The top 12 government programs ever

    Which federal programs and policies succeed in being cost-effective and targeting those who need them most? These two tests are obvious: After all, why would we spend taxpayers' money on a program that isn't worth what it costs or helps those who do not need help?

    April 23, 2014

  • Free trade on steroids: The threat of the Trans-Pacific Partnership

    Many supporters of the proposed Trans-Pacific Partnership, or TPP, trade agreement are arguing that its fate rests on President Obama’s bilateral talks with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe in Japan this week. If Japan and the United States can sort out market access issues for agriculture and automobiles, the wisdom goes, this huge deal — in effect, a North American Free Trade Agreement on steroids — can at last be concluded.

    April 22, 2014

  • Can Hillary Clinton rock the cradle and the world?

    What's most interesting to contemplate is the effect becoming a grandmother will have on Hillary's ambition. It's one of life's unfairnesses that a woman's peak career years often coincide with her peak childbearing years.

    April 22, 2014

  • Chicago Tribune: If Walgreen Co. moves its HQ to Europe, blame Washington’s tax failure

    The Walgreen Co. drugstore chain got its start nearly a century ago in downstate Dixon, Ill., before moving its corporate headquarters to Chicago and eventually to north suburban Deerfield, Ill.
    Next stop? Could be Bern, Switzerland.
    A group of shareholders reportedly is pressuring the giant retail chain for a move to the land of cuckoo clocks. The reason: lower taxes. Much lower taxes.
    If Walgreen changes its legal domicile to Switzerland, where it recently acquired a stake in European drugstore chain Alliance Boots, the company could save big bucks on its corporate income-tax bill. The effective U.S. income-tax rate for Walgreen, according to analysts at Swiss Bank UBS: 37 percent. For Alliance Boots: about 20 percent.

    April 21, 2014

  • Sulphur a future major tourist destination?

    Greta Garbo says, “I want to be alone,” in the 1932 film “Grand Hotel.” That MGM film starred Garbo, John and Lionel Barrymore, Wallace Beery and a young actress from Lawton named Joan Crawford. It told the stories of several different people who were staying at an exclusive hotel of that name in Berlin Germany.
    It was critically well received and it inspired more recent films such as “Gosford Park” and television shows such as “Downton Abbey” in that it detailed the relationship between powerful and wealthy people and those who served them. The film opened amidst much fanfare and it received the Oscar for best picture in the year of its release.

    April 21, 2014

  • St. Louis Post-Dispatch: Why poverty across the world matters to Americans

    A child starving in South Sudan should matter to Americans. That was the message delivered last week by Nancy Lindborg, whose job at the U.S. Agency for International Development is to lead a federal bureau spreading democracy and humanitarian assistance across the world.
    That world has reached a critical danger zone, with three high-level crises combining military conflict with humanitarian catastrophes affecting millions of innocents in Syria, the South Sudan and the Central African Republic.
    But back to that child.

    April 18, 2014

  • Government leadership complicit in overfilling prisons

    One of the thorniest problems facing any society is the question of what to do with transgressors. Obviously, the more complicated a culture becomes, the more factors come into play in trying to figure out what to do with those who choose not to “play by the rules.”

    April 18, 2014

  • My best days are ones normal people take for granted

    It is a weekend for working around the house. My fiancee, Erin, and I have the baby’s room to paint and some IKEA furniture to assemble. I roll out of bed early — 10:30 — and get into my wheelchair. Erin is already making coffee in the kitchen.
    “I started the first wall,” she says. “I love that gray.” Erin never bugs me about sleeping late. For a few months after I was injured in the Boston Marathon bombings, I often slept 15 hours a day. The doctors said my body needed to heal. It must still be healing because I hardly ever see 8 a.m. anymore.

    April 18, 2014

Poll

Do you agree with a state budget proposal that takes some funds away from road and bridge projects to ramp up education funding by $29.85 million per year until schools are receiving $600 million more a year than they are now? In years in which 1 percent revenue growth does not occur in the general fund, the transfer would not take place.

Agree
Disagree
Undecided
     View Results