The Edmond Sun


January 11, 2013

The case against another income tax cut

EDMOND — In the next three weeks Gov. Mary Fallin will release her proposed FY 2014 state budget — a budget that likely will renew her call for legislators to pass a significant cut in Oklahoma’s individual income tax. While cutting the state’s income tax likely will be very popular with key legislators, the more interesting policy question is whether enacting further income tax cuts is the best way to allocate limited state revenues.

Every penny that the Legislature allocates to fund state income tax cuts is one less penny that they can use to fund other budget needs. So, more income tax cuts necessarily mean less spending for education, less spending for roads, less spending for prisons and less money for other types of tax cuts. So when considering new tax cuts, legislators need to consider not just whether the cuts would generate benefits, but whether they will generate the most benefits of all the other options. When one examines the issue through this lens, there are a number of reasons why cutting the state’s income tax should not be the Legislature’s highest priority.

One reason for this is that Oklahoma’s tax burden already is well below the national average. According to data compiled by the U.S. Census Bureau, in 2010 (the last year for which full data is available) Oklahoma’s state and local tax burden (state and local tax collections divided by state personal income) is 8.53 percent, which ranks as the 47th highest out of 50 states — only Alaska, Tennessee and South Dakota rank lower. Oklahoma’s individual income tax is not comparatively high either. According to the same Census Bureau data, Oklahomans paid only 1.67 percent of their personal income in individual income taxes in 2010 — a tax burden that ranks 35th out of the 50 states. Hence, our state individual income tax is clearly not abnormally high compared to the other states.

With this comparatively low level of taxes paid by Oklahomans, we have a comparatively low level of government services received by Oklahomans as well. According to a different set of Census Bureau data, Oklahoma ranks 47th nationally in per-pupil K-12 education expenditures. Even when one adjusts for Oklahoma’s comparatively low income, Oklahoma ranks 33rd out of the 50 states. Investing less in our children’s education is not the ideal way to develop the workforce for a dynamic 21st century economy.

And it’s not just education that suffers from insufficient funding. Oklahoma’s roads and bridges routinely rank among the nation’s worst. Oklahomans’ health, including mental health, routinely ranks among the nation’s poorest. And perhaps the most fitting example of what happens when state leaders fail to make sufficient investments for the future — we have a state Capitol building that is literally crumbling apart.

More state income tax cuts make it more difficult for policymakers to address these other needs — needs that to me are much more pressing, much more concerning, much more troublesome.

In the past some tax cut supporters have dismissed similar claims by arguing that further cuts in the state’s income tax will stimulate faster economic growth, enabling the state to spend even more money on education, health care, roads and prisons. However, the data from states that lack an individual income tax do not support these claims. Since 2000 Oklahoma’s per-capita personal income has outpaced seven of the nine states that lack a personal income tax (source: U.S. Census Bureau). Furthermore, Oklahoma’s median household income — arguably the most relevant economic statistic regarding the well-being of the typical household — has grown faster than the median household income in all nine states that lack a personal income tax. In short, these two key economic indicators (which are confirmed by decades of economic research on the subject) show that cutting state income taxes is not a panacea to prosperity.

The path to prosperity is paved with investments for the future. Let’s hope that this legislative session our leaders recognize that our state’s biggest obstacle in our path is that we haven’t invested enough.


MICKEY HEPNER is the dean of the College of Business Administration at the University of Central Oklahoma. Hepner serves on the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors for The Oklahoma Academy.

Text Only
  • Is English getting dissed?

    Is the English language being massacred by the young, the linguistically untidy and anyone who uses the Internet? Absolutely.
    Is that anything new? Hardly.
    Many words and expressions in common parlance today would have raised the hackles of language scolds in the not-so-distant past. For evidence, let’s look at some examples from recent newspaper articles.

    July 31, 2014

  • 'Too big to fail' equals 'too eager to borrow'

    Four years ago this month, President Barack Obama signed the Dodd-Frank Act into law, promising that the 848-page financial law would “put a stop to taxpayer bailouts once and for all,” he said. But recently, Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren told a Detroit crowd that “the biggest banks are even bigger than they were when they got too big to fail in 2008.”
    Who’s right?

    July 30, 2014

  • Sheltons travel for better life for family

    Some time around 1865 a mixed-race African American couple, William and Mary Shelton, made their way from Mississippi to east Texas. Nothing is known for certain of their origins in he Magnolia state, or the circumstances under which they began their new lives in Texas.

    July 29, 2014

  • Film critic Turan produces book

    Kenneth Turan, who is the film critic for National Public Radio’s “Morning Edition,” has written a book “Not to be Missed, Fifty-Four Favorites from a Life Time of Film.” His list of movies span the gamut from the beginnings of filmmaking through the present day.
    There are some surprising omissions on his list. While he includes two films, “A Touch of Evil” and Chimes at Midnight” made by Orson Welles, and one, “The Third Man,” that Welles starred in but did not direct. He did not however, include “Citizen Kane,” that was the first movie Welles made, that is  often cited by both film critics and historians as a favorite film.

    July 28, 2014

  • Logan County’s disputed zone

    Watchers of “Star Trek” may recall the episode from the original series entitled, “Day of the Dove.” In this episode, Captain Kirk and his crew are forced by a series of circumstances into a confrontation with the Klingons. The conflict eventually resolves after Kirk realizes that the circumstances have been intentionally designed by an alien force which feeds off negative emotions, especially fear and anger. Kirk and his crew communicate this fact to the Klingons and the conflict subsides. No longer feeding upon confrontation, the alien force is weakened and successfully driven away.

    July 28, 2014

  • Russell leads in Sun poll

    Polling results of an unscientific poll at show that Steve Russell, GOP candidate for the 5th District congressional seat, is in the lead with 57 percent of the vote ahead of the Aug. 26 runoff election. Thirty readers participated in the online poll.

    July 28, 2014

  • Healthier and Wealthier? Not in Oklahoma

    Increased copays, decreased coverage, diminished health care access, reduced provider budgets and increased frustration are all the outcomes of the Legislature’s 2014 health care funding decisions. Unlike some years in the past when a languishing state economy forced legislators into making cuts, the undesirable outcomes this year could easily have been avoided.

    July 26, 2014

  • Medicaid reform a necessity

    Historically, education spending by the state of Oklahoma has been the largest budget item. This is no longer the case. In recent years, the state of Oklahoma spends more on Medicaid (operated by the Oklahoma Health Care Authority) than common education and higher education combined, according to the state’s Comprehensive Annual Financial Report.

    July 25, 2014

  • Remembering lessons from 1974

    This week marks the 40th anniversary of an important milestone in America’s constitutional history. On July 24, 1974, the Supreme Court voted 8-0 to order the Nixon White House to turn over audiotapes that would prove the president and his close aides were guilty of criminal violations. This ruling established with crystal clarity that the executive branch could not hide behind the shield of executive privilege to protect itself from the consequences of illegal behavior. It was a triumph for the continued vitality of our constitutional form of government.

    July 25, 2014

  • RedBlueAmerica: Is parenting being criminalized in America?

    Debra Harrell was arrested recently after the McDonald’s employee let her daughter spend the day playing in a nearby park while she worked her shift. The South Carolina woman says her daughter had a cell phone in case of danger, and critics say that children once were given the independence to spend a few unsupervised hours in a park.
    Is it a crime to parent “free-range” kids? Does Harrell deserve her problems? Joel Mathis and Ben Boychuk, the RedBlueAmerica columnists, debate the issue.

    July 24, 2014


The runoff race for the 5th District congressional seat is set for Aug. 26. If the voting were today, which candidate would you support?

Al McAffrey
Tom Guild
     View Results