EDMOND — Oklahoma’s lawsuit-reform debate sadly has revealed that honorable and well-meaning public officials like Gov. Brad Henry and Attorney General Drew Edmondson, when push comes to shove, side with the most reactionary elements of the trial bar.
But this year’s debate revealed a problem even more disturbing than opposition to legal reform. Edmondson has imported to Oklahoma a new model of the office of attorney general that is destructive both to the rule of law and to the welfare of the state.
Traditionally, there has been a bipartisan consensus on the role of the attorney general. He defends the state and state officers in court against lawsuits, defends the state’s criminal convictions on appeal, and provides legal advice to state officials and employees. In the words of a former attorney general of Maine, “For 200 years (attorneys general) defended the states in cases brought by outside parties.”
The attorney general, as one would expect from a lawyer who represents the whole public, never envisioned his role as bringing and winning big-money lawsuits. Rather, the attorney general ensures all laws are fairly and impartially applied in the service of justice for all our citizens — even if this means he loses his case.
In the 1990s, a new model of the office emerged. Political sharks like New York’s attorney general and now governor Eliot Spitzer realized they could use their power to file lawsuits and criminal charges to bludgeon large corporations into big settlements that would make for good headlines. They started with unpopular defendants like the tobacco companies and, once drawing blood, moved on to any other industry with big money and bad publicity.
Along the way, these shrewd politicians discovered a neat deal: They could hire their plaintiff lawyer friends to help bring these lawsuits. The lawyers would reap millions from the extorted settlements and then — coincidentally, I’m sure — make large campaign contributions to the attorney general’s next campaign.
Now this pernicious model has been brought to Oklahoma. Witness Edmondson’s recent arguments against the lawsuit reform bill. He criticized the elimination of joint and several liability, which is a rule providing that, simply because I am a deep pocket, I pay 100 percent of the damages, even if I only caused a fraction of the harm.
He stated, “I cannot for the life of me, figure out why the state would want to limit its own ability to recover damages when the state has been harmed.” He seems never to have considered his job requires he value justice to individual defendants above collecting cash for the state treasury.
The problem with envisioning the attorney general as the state’s chief plaintiffs’ lawyer is it not only undermines the fair and impartial administration of justice, but it also fails on its own terms — these lawsuits economically will harm, not benefit, the state.
Politicians sometimes forget that, as the airlines tell us, we have a choice of who to fly — and businesses have a choice of where they want to be.
Perhaps New York and California can afford to go after their business and health care leaders — there will be plenty of people who still will want or need to do business there.
But if the political leaders of our state continue to give the back of their hand to those people they say we’re trying to attract, they will just pull up stakes and go where they are welcome.
ANDREW SPIROPOULOS is a professor of law at Oklahoma City University and an adjunct scholar at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs. He is a contributor to The Heritage Guide to the Constitution, published by The Heritage Foundation.
Opinion
New attorney-general model harms Oklahoma
- Opinion
-
-
LETTER: Spanish teacher supports Duncan for re-election
To the Editor:
I am a teacher in the Edmond Public School District. For the past 10 years, I have witnessed first-hand the extraordinary work of Kathleen Duncan, president of the Edmond Board of Education. -
LETTER: Former board member endorses newcomer in school board race
To the Editor:
On Feb. 14, Edmond school patrons of District 2 will vote to select a school board member for Edmond Public Schools. This District 2 seat will be a five-year term. The responsibilities of a school board member are mainly two-fold: 1) Select and hire a superintendent or terminate his contract when appropriate; and 2) Develop and implement board policies that are in the best interests of Edmond students and school staff.
It should be noted that a board member has no authority to act in any capacity representative of the school unless he/she is seated at an official, designated school board meeting. -
Science could alter drunkenness, but moral dilemmas remain
According to a recent study described in the Feb. 11 issue of Science News, an ancient Chinese hangover remedy may be just what the doctor ordered as a treatment for alcohol abuse. We’re going to consider this study in a minute, but first, let’s put our problem in historical perspective.
-
Hello, recovery
After a financial crisis that triggered the deepest recession since the Great Depression, it finally appears that the long-awaited economic recovery is here.
-
The Norman Transcript: Smoking, obesity, inactivity push health rank to No. 48
Dr. Terry Cline, Oklahoma’s Commissioner of Health and Secretary of Health and Human Services, has been making the rounds of Oklahoma newspaper editorial boards. He outlines a legislative agenda that gives cities and towns control over tobacco regulation, a stronger graduated driver’s license law to prohibit teens from texting while driving and a health education requirement for public schools.
-
Selective outrage over 'public money to private institutions'
Thanks to Oklahoma’s new Lindsey Nicole Henry Scholarships for Students with Disabilities Program, “at least $700,000 in state public school funds will be paid this year to send special-education students to private schools in Oklahoma,” Kim Archer reported Oct. 17 in the Tulsa World.
-
Medical board goes paperless with success
Reji Varghese is an Edmond resident who is a deputy director of the Oklahoma Board of Medical Licensure and Supervision. His official duties include overseeing the IT functions of that entity. That board hosts monthly meetings at its Oklahoma City office with agendas that usually include more than 40 items dealing with matters such as possible disciplinary action against physicians, physician assistants and other related professions that the nine members of the board regulate.
-
Moving Oklahoma an integral part of the job
There is one industry that literally moves Oklahoma. Whether it is the fresh produce that feeds your family, or the gasoline that fuels your car, Oklahoma has thousands of trucks moving on its roads daily, delivering goods to your hometown.
-
Report shows good news in the numbers
The Oklahoma Office of State Finance provided the state with some great news last week. As you may recall, purchasing reform was one of the first efforts launched by the Oklahoma House as part of the Government Modernization initiative. During the 2008-09 legislative sessions, we acted on reports from IBM and Treya Consultants and rewrote the state’s purchasing laws to provide a special emphasis on managing the state’s millions of dollars of spend in a strategic manner that hopefully will match best procurement practices of free-market business entities.
-
School nurse supports Duncan’s re-election bid
To the Editor:
On Feb. 14, residents of Edmond Public Schools District 2 have an opportunity to continue the positive momentum of the state of Oklahoma by re-electing Kathleen Duncan to the Edmond Board of Education. A healthy public school system makes our state more attractive to both families and businesses. - More Opinion Headlines
-
LETTER: Spanish teacher supports Duncan for re-election
