Opinion
New attorney-general model harms Oklahoma
EDMOND — Oklahoma’s lawsuit-reform debate sadly has revealed that honorable and well-meaning public officials like Gov. Brad Henry and Attorney General Drew Edmondson, when push comes to shove, side with the most reactionary elements of the trial bar.
But this year’s debate revealed a problem even more disturbing than opposition to legal reform. Edmondson has imported to Oklahoma a new model of the office of attorney general that is destructive both to the rule of law and to the welfare of the state.
Traditionally, there has been a bipartisan consensus on the role of the attorney general. He defends the state and state officers in court against lawsuits, defends the state’s criminal convictions on appeal, and provides legal advice to state officials and employees. In the words of a former attorney general of Maine, “For 200 years (attorneys general) defended the states in cases brought by outside parties.”
The attorney general, as one would expect from a lawyer who represents the whole public, never envisioned his role as bringing and winning big-money lawsuits. Rather, the attorney general ensures all laws are fairly and impartially applied in the service of justice for all our citizens — even if this means he loses his case.
In the 1990s, a new model of the office emerged. Political sharks like New York’s attorney general and now governor Eliot Spitzer realized they could use their power to file lawsuits and criminal charges to bludgeon large corporations into big settlements that would make for good headlines. They started with unpopular defendants like the tobacco companies and, once drawing blood, moved on to any other industry with big money and bad publicity.
Along the way, these shrewd politicians discovered a neat deal: They could hire their plaintiff lawyer friends to help bring these lawsuits. The lawyers would reap millions from the extorted settlements and then — coincidentally, I’m sure — make large campaign contributions to the attorney general’s next campaign.
Now this pernicious model has been brought to Oklahoma. Witness Edmondson’s recent arguments against the lawsuit reform bill. He criticized the elimination of joint and several liability, which is a rule providing that, simply because I am a deep pocket, I pay 100 percent of the damages, even if I only caused a fraction of the harm.
He stated, “I cannot for the life of me, figure out why the state would want to limit its own ability to recover damages when the state has been harmed.” He seems never to have considered his job requires he value justice to individual defendants above collecting cash for the state treasury.
The problem with envisioning the attorney general as the state’s chief plaintiffs’ lawyer is it not only undermines the fair and impartial administration of justice, but it also fails on its own terms — these lawsuits economically will harm, not benefit, the state.
Politicians sometimes forget that, as the airlines tell us, we have a choice of who to fly — and businesses have a choice of where they want to be.
Perhaps New York and California can afford to go after their business and health care leaders — there will be plenty of people who still will want or need to do business there.
But if the political leaders of our state continue to give the back of their hand to those people they say we’re trying to attract, they will just pull up stakes and go where they are welcome.
ANDREW SPIROPOULOS is a professor of law at Oklahoma City University and an adjunct scholar at the Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs. He is a contributor to The Heritage Guide to the Constitution, published by The Heritage Foundation.
- Opinion
-
-
A media-twisted idea of normalcy
Last week’s most telling news story had nothing to do with the mosque. Or the election struggles of Alaska Sen. Lisa Murkowski. Or the president’s vacation at the Vineyard.
No, the one story that reveals more than any other about what is going on in America concerns the Miss Universe contest. -
Education reform must be a priority
This fall brings another school year. However, the next years are critical for Oklahoma‘s economy and much rides on improving public education. Budget cuts made this year will have a lasting effect. The issue is what actions can be taken to improve our educational system. It doesn’t just rest on reforms in education alone. We need a complete re-thinking of government and realignment of priorities.
-
It’s time for Congress to pay up
Thank God there are still a few common-sense public servants in the U.S. government. Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates is one of them.
-
Hatred blinds, distorts values
Sunday night the United States opened its arms to two young men from Uganda. I was at the airport when Richard Kirabira arrived to join his friend Charles Mugabi who arrived last week.
Both of them have received scholarships to East Central University in Ada, and they regard this opportunity as a priceless blessing to themselves, their families and ultimately, to their country. -
Business leaders: Obama agenda bad for economy
Distressing new economic headlines just keep coming. Unemployment claims reached a nine-month high in early August. Existing home sales tumbled by 27 percent from June to July, representing the largest one-month drop ever recorded. Sales of new homes reached the lowest levels recorded since 1963. The stock market is down 11 percent, and new GDP numbers are dismal.
-
Roofer registration protects homeowners
Consumers will reap rewards from state homebuilders’ legislative efforts to tighten contractor registration requirements.
The first involves roofer registration legislation, where roofers will register with the state’s Construction Industries Board. Roofers will provide a small fee, verify their insurance and will then be required to display their registration number on all of their trucks and signs. -
Mangum explores tourism, historical roots
Nobel Prize-winning author Nadine Gordimer has written about her youth in South Africa in an essay titled “A South African Childhood” that was included in a collection of her essays recently published under the title “Telling Times.” Gordimer grew up in the 1930s in a small town in the Transvaal region of that nation, and she wrote about how she was reminded of the farming communities she visited as a child when she saw the production of the play “Oklahoma” in Johannesburg in the 1950s.
-
Unconstitutional tax increases bear watching
You may recall two updates that I wrote shortly after the conclusion of this year’s legislative session. I explained my opposition to fee and tax increases and talked about how the increases would hurt Oklahoma’s economy by punishing and disincentivizing Oklahoma small business owners.
-
Broadband funds a boost to rural Oklahoma
Like highways, phone service or electricity, broadband Internet service has become a vital part of our nation’s infrastructure and an important tool in education, business and economic development.
-
We the people are sovereign
Under the Constitution, consent of the governed provides the authority to govern. This concept was declared in the Declaration of Independence and reaffirmed in the preamble to the Constitution. Sovereignty of the people is the key precept of a free republic.
- More Opinion Headlines
-
A media-twisted idea of normalcy
