Opinion
How to help autistic children in Oklahoma
One of the most hotly debated measures during Oklahoma’s 2008 legislative session was Senate Bill 1537 — colloquially referred to as “Nick’s Law” — which would have required insurance companies doing business in Oklahoma to cover autism. Though the bill made it through the Senate, it did not make it out of committee in the House.
Autism is a brain-development disorder that affects about 6,000 Oklahoma children. It manifests itself as a pattern of symptoms of which the primary characteristics are problems with communication, limited interests and repetitive behavior. While autism is not curable, early intervention and treatment of the type that would be mandated under this bill have been shown to be important to the long-term life prospects of autistic children.
For proponents of an autism mandate, the existence of these clear benefits to autistic children makes the case for an autism mandate self-evident. But there is a potential downside to health-care mandates such as an autism mandate: They can drive up insurance costs and end up pricing people out of the market. The costs of autism coverage have to be borne by someone, and it is folly to think that the full incidence of any mandate will fall entirely on insurance company profits.
Some of the cost increase will be passed along to consumers in the form of higher premiums. This is not the real cost of the mandate, however, as this is just a transfer of resources. The real cost of the mandate will come from those individuals who are priced out of the market as a result of the higher premiums. Thus the size and impact of any proposed autism mandate is an important issue and a primary reason for careful study.
Another, more innovative, solution comes to mind after reading a May 30 story in The Oklahoman headlined “What Promise Does Ohio Hold for Autistic Boy From Oklahoma?” It seems that an Oklahoma family decided to respond to the failed passage of “Nick’s Law” by selling their home and moving to Ohio.
Why would they undertake such a drastic move? Because Ohio has a school voucher program for autistic children. In Ohio, parents of autistic children can choose to have their children educated through their local school district or through private special education programs. For those who choose an alternative school, up to $20,000 of taxpayer money follows the child.
While an autism scholarship program for Oklahoma would not address all the financial issues surrounding autism treatment, it would have several appealing qualities.
First, unlike a mandate, it does not harm others by crowding out private insurance.
Second, a tax-credit scholarship program would focus attention on the issue of early diagnosis and treatment. Thanks to a provision in Oklahoma’s constitution known as the Blaine Amendment, such a program in Oklahoma likely would need to be funded through a charitable tax credit rather than a voucher.
Third, a scholarship program provides needed flexibility for parents to seek and craft the best treatment solution for their child. Given the fact that autism is a bundle of symptoms of varying severity, the flexibility that choice allows seems especially important.
Fourth, any tax revenue lost because of charitable donations to an autism scholarship program would be, at least in part, offset by the fact that students using the scholarships would no longer be enrolled in the public schools.
Economics teaches us there are few “free lunches” when it comes to public policy, which often involves trading off the benefits received by one group against the costs imposed on another. Nick’s Law, for example, raised concern and uncertainty among policymakers about who might be harmed by rising insurance costs.
A tax credit for donations to scholarship programs geared to autistic children, however, might be close to a free lunch for the reasons described. Though it’s no panacea, it is a simple and elegant solution that would help a large number of families.
JOSHUA HALL is an assistant professor of economics at Beloit College. For more information on school choice for special-needs children, visit Choice Remarks (okschoolchoice.blogspot.com).
- Opinion
-
-
Ready, set, wait for grocery tax cut
This past week the Oklahoma State Senate approved a measure to eliminate the sales tax on groceries. However, you shouldn’t be counting all the money you will save just yet — unless you are already preparing your shopping list for 2016.
-
Spring break ideas for families
The old saying, “No matter how long the winter, spring is sure to follow” comes to mind this time of year. Robins are taking wing and the daffodils are starting to peek out of the ground.
For many boys and girls, the traditional “spring break” cannot come soon enough, and most Oklahoma schools will observe this time off between March 15 and March 19. However, some school boards do not schedule a spring break, and a few opt to schedule a one- or two-day break only. -
Daring to dream can bring fulfillment
The Everly Brothers sang, “All I have to do is dream.” Dreams are of pretty cool stuff but also about aspirations and hopes for a lifetime. Growing up we all have dreams we reach for. To some it’s in sports, others politics, others to be in the movies. We “dream” of what things will be like when we only get older.
-
Deficits have their dark sides
Once upon a time there was a deficit. By our standards, it wouldn’t amount to much, but in its day, it was big enough and unruly enough that it managed to set historical forces in motion and we’re still hearing echoes of that little deficit today.
Now this little deficit, like all deficits, didn’t have a name of its own. It was just called “deficit.” And, like many other deficits, it was cultivated, nourished and born with the idea it would serve a good purpose. This particular deficit was meant to cover a war. -
Resident offers health care rebuttal
Congressman Tom Cole continued the Republicans’ misleading depiction of the health insurance reform bill and congressional machinations related to it in his essay in Tuesday’s Edmond Sun. He included so many inaccuracies that it is hard to clarify everything.
He falsely called the proposal a “government takeover of health care.” Health care is delivered by providers. Under both the current system and the proposed revisions of the system, a consumer selects a provider based on whether or not there is a means to pay that particular provider. -
Partisan political tactics stifle health-care debate
The process Democrats are pursuing to pass government-run health care has become as flawed as the legislation itself. And that’s really saying something. From the beginning, the attempt to force through a government takeover of health care has been marked by disregard for the views of the American people. Now, Democratic leaders are disregarding standard legislative procedures and well-established precedents, as well.
-
South of border business deals could expand local economy
There is one of the original copies of the Magna Carta on display in the British Museum in London, England. That document, which was signed by King John of England in 1215 under duress, imposed limits on the power of the monarchy.
A copy of the Magna Carta, along with the American Declaration of Independence, the U.S. Constitution and the Oklahoma Constitution are included in the volumes that contain the statutes enacted by the Oklahoma Legislature. Paragraph 41 of the Magna Carta mandated that “All merchants shall have safe and secure conduct, to go out of, and to come into England, and to stay there, and to pass as well by land and water, for buying and selling by the ancient and allowed customs, without any evil tolls.” -
Oklahoma College Savings Plan an investment
In today’s workforce a college degree is a vital tool for landing a great job, and the necessity for higher education only will increase in the coming years. Studies show that workers with college degrees earn, on average, twice as much over a lifetime than those with only a high school diploma.
A college education is an investment for a lifetime. Unfortunately, affording college is beyond the means of some families and, especially in today’s economic climate, a struggle for many others. -
Budget-cutting measures make way through House
This week marks the House of Representatives’ deadline for voting on legislation before it goes to the Senate, so this is the time of year when representatives begin to spend a significant deal of time on the House floor. It also is the first major test for many of the more interesting and controversial issues.
One of the bills recently considered by the House was House Bill 3393, which was sponsored by state Rep. Jason Nelson. Nelson has invested significant effort in developing HB 3393, which provides a method for special needs students to go to schools which provide them with needed support. -
The moral argument for health insurance reform
Grace is a sweet little 6-year-old girl who likes soccer and science. Matthew is a curly-haired 3-year-old who likes balls, books and going to his Bible study.
- More Opinion Headlines
-
Ready, set, wait for grocery tax cut
