The Edmond Sun

Opinion

April 25, 2013

Internet taxation: fair or foul?

WASHINGTON, D.C. — As a general rule, whenever one hears members of Congress talking about “fairness,” you should hold on tight to your wallet. That’s certainly the case with the proposed “Marketplace Fairness Act,” which has been under consideration in the Senate. The bill is aimed at leveling the sales-tax playing field between Internet merchants and so-called brick-and-mortar retailers.

Supporters argue that simple fairness demands the changes. But that fairness will come at a high cost to online businesses and American consumers. Congress should click the “delete” button on this ill-advised proposal.

The ongoing debate over Internet sales taxes actually has little to do with the Internet. Rather, it is a debate over the proper reach of state tax collectors. It has its roots in a 1992 Supreme Court case regarding a distinctly pre-Internet business: mail-order catalogs.

The state of North Dakota had sued an office-supply company called Quill, arguing that the firm should have been collecting sales taxes from North Dakotans buying items through Quill’s mail-order business. Quill had no stores, warehouses or staff in North Dakota, but the state argued that the retailer had to collect the prairie states’ sales taxes anyway.

The Supreme Court soundly rejected North Dakota’s claims, ruling that unless a firm has some physical presence, or nexus, within the state, North Dakota couldn’t require Quill to collect its taxes.

At the time, the decision hardly seemed monumental, attracting the attention only of a few mail-order junkies. But the principle it established became critical to electronic commerce in the Internet age. Internet sellers could not be required to collect taxes unless they had some physical connection to the taxing state.

The legislation now pending in Congress would overturn Quill Corp. vs. North Dakota and open up e-commerce providers to mandates imposed by tax authorities in other states. The argument for such tax mandates is temptingly simple. Why, argue supporters, should old-fashioned physical stores pay sales taxes while their competitors in cyberspace get off scot- and tax-free? The rule is unfair, some non-digital retailers argue, favoring one type of business over another.

Their argument is not without merit. Ideally, taxes should not distort the marketplace. But it this case, the proposed solution — allowing state tax collectors to force remote merchants to collect their taxes — would do more harm than good.

First, the idea that Internet retailers are exempt from taxation is false. In fact, 17 of the 20 largest Internet vendors pay taxes in 46 or more states. Many of these, such as Staples and Office Depot, have extensive brick-and-mortar operations nationwide, making their sales fully taxable. And the biggest e-commerce player, Amazon.com, is collecting taxes for a growing number of states, as it builds out a network of warehouses nationwide.

Of course, that stills leaves thousands of nexus-less Internet retailers who don’t collect out-of-state taxes. But forcing them to do so would come at a cost. Most obviously, expanded tax collection would provide a windfall to state treasuries, increasing consumer costs by billions.

But that’s only the start. Collecting and keeping track of payments for the 9,600 some sales tax jurisdictions in the U.S. would be a significant burden for smaller vendors, even with the help of computer programs. And the prospect of tax audits from the 45 states with sales taxes would be even more daunting. Moreover, vendors in the five states without sales taxes would be forced to collect for the states that do levy sales tax.

There’s also a potential cost in lost privacy, as vendors collect and store residence and purchase data on their customers.

If states wish to impose such costs on their retailers, that’s their prerogative. States can regulate businesses within their borders. But the Marketplace Fairness Act would allow states to regulate the businesses of other states. Retailers would be subject to edicts and mandates from states with which they have no connection. And because they have no connection, state politicians would have little reason to worry about the effect of their taxes on the retailers.

Economically, the costs — ranging from job losses to reduced investment — resulting from the burdens imposed on retailers would be borne by the home state, not the taxing state. And politically, there would be little reason for out-of-state politicians to care, as the owners and employees wouldn’t vote in the taxing states elections.

This is the sort of harm the Founders — and the Supreme Court in Quill — feared. By abandoning the protections of federalism, we’re all left worse off. Congress should not open the gates to that dangerous path — even in the name of fairness.

JAMES GATTUSO is senior research fellow in regulatory policy at The Heritage Foundation. Readers may write to the author in care of The Heritage Foundation, 214 Massachusetts Avenue NE, Washington, D.C. 20002; He also may be contacted online via www.heritage.org.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • OTHER VIEW: Newsday: Lapses on deadly diseases demand explanation

    When we heard that the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention had created a potentially lethal safety risk by improperly sending deadly pathogens — like anthrax — to other laboratories around the country, our first reaction was disbelief.

    July 22, 2014

  • Holding government accountable for open meeting violations

    A few weeks ago I wrote about the recent success of three important government transparency proposals which will go into law this year.

    July 21, 2014

  • GUEST OPINION — Oklahoma GOP voters want educational choices

    A Braun Research survey released in January showed that Oklahoma voters — Republicans, Democrats, and Independents alike — favor parental choice in education.

    July 21, 2014

  • HEY HINK: IRS interferes with citizens’ rights of free speech

    The patient is gravely ill. We have detected traces of a deadly venom in the bloodstream. We don’t know how widespread the poison is, but we know, if not counteracted, toxins of this kind can rot the patient’s vital organs and could ultimately prove fatal.

    July 19, 2014

  • 130408_NT_BEA_good kids We're raising a generation of timid kids

    A week ago, a woman was charged with leaving her child in the car while she went into a store. Her 11-year-old child. This week, a woman was arrested for allowing her 9-year-old daughter to go to the park alone. Which raises just one question: America, what the heck is wrong with you?

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • RedBlueAmerica: What should the U.S. do about illegal immigrant children?

    The crisis along the southern U.S. border has politicians and immigration officials scrambling. More than 52,000 children, mostly from Central American nations, have arrived so far this year. The Department of Homeland Security is running out of space to hold them all.
    President Barack Obama is asking Congress for $3.7 billion in borrowed money from taxpayers to cover the growing “care, feeding and transportation costs of unaccompanied children and family groups” when our own veterans are not taken care of. Texas Gov. Rick Perry criticized the president’s plan, saying more money should go toward securing the border.

    July 17, 2014

  • VA scandal highlights the need to change Pentagon spending priorities

    The ongoing Department of Veterans Affairs scandal raises an important question: When our veterans are being denied access to basic health care, why is the Pentagon squandering billions of dollars on programs that do not benefit our military forces? Is there a link in organization attitudes?

    July 16, 2014

  • For better politics, it’s time for some raging moderates

    Like more than 20 percent of my fellow Californians, I am now classified as a no-party-preference voter, registered to vote but with no affiliation to any of the state’s political parties.
    I am for lower taxes and for marriage equality. I am tough on crime and I am anti-abortion. I believe that a pathway to citizenship is a necessary part of immigration reform and that student test scores should be a critical component of teacher evaluations.

    July 15, 2014

  • Father on mission to stop gun violence

    Since his son died six weeks ago as collateral damage to a troubled young man’s wish for vengeance, Richard Martinez has been asked whom he holds responsible.
    “I’m responsible,” the California lawyer answers, referring to most Americans’ failure to push harder to change gun laws after earlier mass shootings. “All those kids died and none of us did anything.”

    July 14, 2014

  • The Kansas City Star: Obama must end the public information barriers

    Mr. President, you have a public information problem. Again. Several months ago, journalism organizations complained about a lack of access for news photographers to pertinent presidential events.

    July 14, 2014

Poll

If the Republican runoff for the 5th District congressional seat were today, which candidate would you vote for?

Patrice Douglas
Steve Russell
Undecided
     View Results