The Edmond Sun


December 27, 2013

New report finds school accountability in limbo

2 in 3 ‘failing’ schools under NCLB no longer ‘failing’ under waivers

WASHINGTON, D.C. —  After years of criticizing No Child Left Behind, over 40 states are now taking a different approach to improving their low-performing schools. Armed with waivers from the federal law, these states are designing and implementing accountability systems based on relative, rather than absolute, measures of school performance. As a result, accountability systems and the low-performing schools they identify are dramatically different, according to a new report from the New America Foundation.

Using data collected from over 20,000 schools in 16 states during the transition from NCLB to waivers, “It’s All Relative” finds major upheaval in school accountability: nearly 4,500, or 65 percent, of schools in NCLB improvement were eased from these interventions under waivers. In other words, two in three formerly “failing” schools are no longer identified by states’ new school accountability systems. And in five states, at least half of the schools identified by NCLB, but not waivers, had previously been in corrective action or restructuring, missing their performance targets for at least four years running.

“The untold story of waivers is that with little warning, hundreds of so-called “failing” schools suddenly weren’t “failing” anymore,” said Anne Hyslop, author of the report and a policy analyst for New America’s Education Policy Program.

The primary reason behind these changes is not additional performance measures, or complicated school grading systems, but rather the new relative approach for identifying the worst schools. With NCLB, schools in improvement fell short of a pre-determined performance standard: Adequate Yearly Progress, or AYP. With waivers, however, the “standard” is often the number of schools that must be identified — at least 15 percent of schools. This decreased how many schools were placed in federal interventions by one-third, on average, in the 16 states (Arizona, Delaware, Florida, Indiana, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Nevada, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Virginia). But there is significant variation: Nevada identified over 85 percent fewer schools under waivers, while Rhode Island only 12 percent fewer. And in order to reach the 15 percent threshold, five states actually named more schools for interventions under waivers than they ever did under NCLB.

“This accountability strategy creates a finite number of school improvement slots,” Hyslop noted.

 “At the same time, states were given flexibility to measure school performance differently, changing how they viewed a school’s relative success. While it may be too soon to tell if 15 percent is the ‘right’ number or if states have chosen the “right” performance measures, landing in the bottom 15 percent matters for schools, teachers, students, and families, and it matters now.”

The stakes for identifying the “right” schools are higher than ever, Hyslop explains, because school interventions under waivers are becoming more focused and rigorous.

She recommends an ambitious federal and state research agenda for waiver implementation, especially as the U.S. Department of Education begins to renew states’ waivers during the 2013–14 school year.

“The only way to determine if waivers are improving school, educator, and student performance is to gather evidence, carefully and systematically, on what is happening and why — and make changes if needed.”

Text Only
  • Dr. Fielding’s variance denied by close vote

    Reverse-angle parking will continue at the 13 N. University Drive office of Dr. Brad Fielding. The Edmond City Council rejected a variance request by the local optometrist to end the city’s pilot project in front of his medical facility.
    Councilman Nick Massey and Councilwoman Victoria Caldwell supported Fielding’s variance request that was dismissed in a 3-2 vote.
    Four parking lines were striped late last year at Fielding’s business after the city opened new bicycle lanes along University. The city cites the safety for bicyclists and motorists who traditionally depart while backing into traffic as the main reasons for introducing reverse-angle parking.

    April 15, 2014

  • Sequoyah Sequoyah names students of the month

    Sequoyah teachers chose the following students as students of the month for being good role models, conscientious students, diligent workers, and respectful individuals

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • OCU planning Earth Day activities

    Oklahoma City University will celebrate Earth Day with events on April 22. The events are free to the public and will be in the McDaniel University Center near Florida Avenue and Northwest 26th Street.

    April 12, 2014

  • Ruff Draft Student newspaper, magazines take top honors at contest

    Ruff Draft, the student newspaper produced by staffs at all three Edmond high schools, recently took top honors in the Oklahoma Scholastic Media competition, which is conducted in coordination with the Gaylord School of Journalism at the University of Oklahoma.

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Art Show UCO puts the spotlight on design graduates

    The University of Central Oklahoma Department of Design will present “Defeaters of Dull: The Design Senior Show” from 6-8 p.m. April 17 at the First National Center, 120 N. Robinson Ave., Suite 730W, in downtown Oklahoma City.

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Gala to celebrate global programs

    The University of Central Oklahoma’s Office of Global Affairs will present the International House Night Market Gala from 6-9 p.m. April 18 at the UCO International House, 912 N. Chowning Ave. in Edmond, just north of the main campus.
    Now in its second year, the gala’s 2014 theme is “A Fusion of Art and Cultural Storytelling.”
    Attendees will enjoy dinner, live and silent auctions, entertainment and the presentation of the award for Promoting Cross-Cultural Understanding to Pam Washington, Ph.D., dean of Central’s College of Fine Arts and Design, as well as the recognition of Zhongying Wang, president of Tiptop Energy Production US LLC, as a top contributor to Cross-Cultural Understanding.

    April 12, 2014

  • Oklahoma Christian presents band, orchestra concerts

    The Oklahoma Christian University music department will present its final instrumental concerts of the school year next week.

    April 12, 2014

  • safety 5.jpg 500-plus Edmond students visit safety village

    More than 500 local students have learned about safety from Edmond firefighters in recent days.
    Mid-day Friday, students from Washington Irving Elementary School were at the Edmond Fire Department’s Children’s Safety Village, a child-size, life safety education center where children learn in a hands-on environment. The village is complete with a city park, buildings, streets, traffic lights, a railroad crossing, a water feature and utility-like infrastructure.

    April 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Edmond student named National Achievement Scholarship winner

    National Merit Scholarship Corporation announced this week the names of about 800 outstanding Black American high school seniors who have won Achievement Scholarship® awards through the National Achievement Scholarship Program. These awards, totaling more than $2 million, are financed by grants from 31 corporate organizations and professional associations, and by National Merit Scholarship Corporation.

    April 11, 2014

  • Perry takes on Summit principal position

    Shana Perry was named the new principal of Summit Middle School starting for the 2014-15 school year. The Edmond Board of Education voted on the personnel change at its regularly scheduled meeting Monday.

    April 10, 2014