The Edmond Sun

Sports

September 18, 2007

Why is there no playoff system in major college football?

While high school sports are not perfect, at least they have this one right.

Can you imagine if high school football had its own version of the Bowl Championship Series. It would be an absolute nightmare.

At this point in the season Edmond Memorial and North would already be eliminated from the picture, with a couple of early season losses. Memorial’s losses are by a combined six points, so that would be a joke.

Santa Fe’s strength of schedule would have taken a hit because it ventured out of the OSSAA, to play KC Rockhurst, or would it? Voters could swing either way. They could go by the Hawklet’s history, or they could go off of their 6-3 season from a year ago.

If OCS lost again, who knows?

Deer Creek would be in a good position right now, because its only loss is to one of the state’s best teams.

Wouldn’t this be a terrible scenario?

This is what teams like Texas and Wisconsin face.

Sure, Texas can still make it to a BCS bowl, not that I really believe that, but if they happened to win the Big 12 title, they would be there.

Texas dropped from No. 4 to No. 7, and deservedly so, after their less than stellar performance against Arkansas State. But since when should a team be punished for a win?

Wisconsin and Ohio State faced similar drops in the polls after bad performances, but how much was that affected by Michigan’s recent collapse?

The thing that upsets me the most is ESPN.

It’s the station I watch non-stop because I just can’t get enough college football, but the way they rank conferences is beyond me.

They had the SEC and PAC-10, one and two. Not much of an argument there. But, don’t feed me this garbage that Oregon’s 39-7 win over Michigan was huge.

Michigan is a team that has lost three of its last four games, going back to last year.

And don’t act like Ohio State’s win over Washington was that impressive either.

Washington has never proved to be better than mediocre under Tyrone Willingham.

The PAC-10 will always be Southern Cal and the nine dwarfs. These pansies don’t even play a conference championship game.

It’s sad that ESPN’s Gameday trio of Kirk Herbstreit, Lee Corso and Chris Fowler, influence so many voters.

Herbsteit announced to the college football world on Saturday night that USC had proven its No. 1 ranking with the win over Nebraska.

If Southern Cal had beaten Nebraska 49-31 at Memorial Stadium in 1998, then I would agree that they are for real. But beating a team coached by Bill Callahan, that since his arrival has never proved itself to be among the elite teams, how is this a big win?

Heck, one of Nebraska’s biggest games in conference play will be against Oklahoma State, the team that travelled to Troy State and lost. If you’re a program on the rise, how do you justify signing a home-and-home contract with these Trojans? I’m not knocking on OSU, but just the fact that they travelled to Troy, Alabama, for a game is embarrassing enough. Not to mention getting blown out by them.

Anyway, who cares? Lets just ditch this madness, and go to a playoff system. The NCAA would still be raking in the money, football fans would get a few extra games, and college football would finally have a true national champion. One that is not based on the opionion of the “East Coast Trio.”

Text Only
Sports
  • 021012 mem@nmn b3.jpg Bulldogs, Lady 'Dogs win in Norman

    Faced with its last opportunity of the regular season to pull off an upset, Norman High came up just short against Class 6A’s second-ranked Edmond Memorial on Friday. The Bulldogs used a second-half Tiger scoring drought to pull away and then hold on for the 59-54 victory.

    February 11, 2012 3 Photos

  • Santa Fe girls stay perfect vs. Patriots

    The Edmond Santa Fe Lady Wolves turned a 18-6 first-quarter run into a 66-31 victory over the Putnam City West Lady Patriots Friday night in Oklahoma City to remain undefeated for the season.

    February 11, 2012

  • Wolves fall to Putnam City West

    The Edmond Santa Fe Wolves basketball team gave up 11 points in the final period against the Putnam City West Patriots and dropped their second straight contest 40-35 in Oklahoma City Friday night.

    February 11, 2012

  • 021012 DC-guth b1.jpg Deer Creek trims Bluejays' wings

    Despite sinking only one basket in the fourth quarter against rival Guthrie Friday night, the Deer Creek Antlers came away with a 43-39 win over the Bluejays.

    February 11, 2012 1 Photo

  • OCA teams split vs. Agra

    The Oklahoma Christian Academy teams split their games against Agra Friday night in the District tournament.

    February 11, 2012

  • Memorial heads into dual state on win streak

    The Edmond Memorial wrestling team got two duals wins this week, one on senior night.
    All three of the Bulldog seniors got wins by fall on Tuesday, when the team honored their graduating players. Ry Huff won at 220 pounds, Zach Bradshaw at 182 and Derek Hackett at 160.

    February 11, 2012

  • MEMORIAL TRACK.jpg Memorial track teams win HS Invitational at OU

    The Edmond Memorial track and field teams won the Oklahoma High School Invitational at the University of Oklahoma on Friday.

    February 11, 2012 1 Photo

  • 021012 DC-guth g1.jpg Lady Antlers top rival Guthrie

    The Deer Creek girls used a balanced scoring attack and solid early defense to defeat rival Guthrie Friday night.

    February 10, 2012 2 Photos

  • 020912 OSU Liz Donohoe.jpg Cowgirls hold off Texas Tech

    Tiffany Bias scored 10 points — four of them coming on free throws in the final minute — as Oklahoma State held off Texas Tech 53-49 on Wednesday at Gallagher-Iba Arena.

    February 9, 2012 1 Photo

  • Eagles, Lady Eagles win at Carney

    The Oklahoma Christian Academy teams won at Carney Tuesday night.

    February 9, 2012

Poll

Voters in the Edmond Public School District 2 will go to the polls from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Feb. 14 to decide between school board candidates Steve Roy and Kathleen Duncan. District 2 is roughly centered in northwest Edmond. Who will get your vote?

Steve Roy
Kathleen Duncan
     View Results