The Edmond Sun

Sports Opinion

May 28, 2009

SPRUILL : No need to make votes public

Starting in 2010, ballots in the final regular-season USA Today coaches’ college football poll will be confidential.

That’s not necessarily a bad thing. Though we will have one more season to enjoy it.

The current format fuels rivalries, allows us to see how loyal coaches are to their conference and former school’s, while some votes just make us shake our heads. It’s always fun to see the votes of Mack Brown, Mike Leach, Pete Carroll, and the always lovable Howard Schnellenberger. Bob Stoops didn’t use his vote last season, so he was already left out of the equation.

While it would be the end of an era — votes were made public starting in 2005 — coaches would no longer have a need to show loyalty, though some will. In my opinion, coaches do a great job during the season when their votes are kept private, so really, it’s no big deal.

Other’s don’t see it that way and for good reason. There’s a lot riding on that final poll, after all, it accounts for 1/3 of the BCS formula.

"When I was a voter, I liked every coach putting it out there to see where it stands. I liked being accountable,” Ole Miss head football coach Houston Nutt, told the Associated Press.

Former Baylor football coach, Grant Teaff, who is the executive director of the American Football Coaches Association, believes this is the way to get the truest vote. The AFCA took the advice of Gallup, who studied college football’s way of voting, and recommended ways to make it more accurate.

"Gallup said, 'Look, why do you think they have curtains and booths for voting?'" Teaff told AP. "They said it's because you get the truest vote from an anonymous vote."

Exactly. There will be no more reason for coaches not to vote if they have one, making it a better poll.

Some coaches will want to share their votes with the public, some will not, but at least they will have that option. There’s just too much riding on the votes, and for once it appears that college football is heading in the right direction.

1
Text Only
Sports Opinion
  • My 2010 moment

    First off, I’d like to thank the Edmond sporting community for accepting me into their fold, or at least accepting me as much as possible for a journalist. It has been a great five-and a half months and I’ve had the opportunity to witness some prime time moments while at The Sun.

    January 1, 2011

  • SPRUIL: Woods scandal not that shocking Charles Barkley warned us about it in 1993. Professional athletes should not be role models.

    December 3, 2009

  • SPRUILL: Woods scandal not so shocking Charles Barkley warned us about it in 1993. Professional athletes should not be role models.

    Sir Charles gave us this gem back then stating, “A million guys can dunk a basketball in jail, should they be role models?”

    Just can’t do it. I remember vividly the day I learned this valuable lesson, it was when I got my copy of Sports Illustrated with Sooner quarterback Charles Thompson being ushered to jail in his infamous orange jumpsuit.

    December 3, 2009

  • HARRISON : It’s time for some hoops With Bedlam in the rearview mirror and talk of freezing temperatures and possible snow this week it can only mean one thing. The winter sports season is upon us.

    November 30, 2009

  • SPRUIL: 'Dogs have nothing to lose Bulldogs have a chance to break another streak, which is to attempt to end the east sides dominance — Jenks and Union have combined to win 13 straight Class 6A state titles.

    November 19, 2009

  • SPRUILL: UCO loaded for another run No. 18-ranked Central Oklahoma appears to be loaded for another deep run in the NCAA Division II tournament.

    It’s only November and the Bronchos have only played one game, but what they showed against Emporia State in a 116-114 double-overtime win was incredible.

    November 17, 2009

  • SPRUIL: Playoff picture still cloudy With most of the district’s already decided — a few key matchups still remain — it’s time to start looking at the playoff picture.

    We know Edmond Memorial, Edmond North and Oklahoma Christian are in the playoffs. Deer Creek is on life support, while Oklahoma Christian Academy and Edmond Santa Fe are done for the year following Friday night.

    November 3, 2009

  • SPRUILL: OU's Bradford still livin' the dream There’s still no guarantee that Oklahoma quarterback Sam Bradford will play this season. But Sooner fan or not, you have to love the Heisman Trophy winner’s attitude.

    His first start could come this week against Baylor, or it could be against Texas. You will not hear any crying from Bradford, though, that is for certain.

    The media has questioned his decision about coming back. He could have been the No. 1 pick in the NFL Draft, instead he gets injured in the opener and now his future is in question.

    But what seems so shocking to some across the country, really isn’t that shocking at all. Bradford is living his dream. The dream of any former high school star in the state of Oklahoma that wants to play in either Stillwater or Norman.

    October 6, 2009

  • HARRISON: Local teams draw favorable regional assignments With the end of the regular season fast approaching, local softball teams are turning their attention towards next week’s regional tournaments. While Edmond Santa Fe is the only squad that will be at home next week, all four teams have a legitimate shot at state.

    September 30, 2009

  • SPRUILL: Edmond recovering from split Things are shaping up for another great football season for local teams.

    As it stands, Edmond still has two undefeated teams in Edmond North and Oklahoma Christian School. And there are signs the big three have reached a near full recovery from the spit.

    September 15, 2009