The Edmond Sun

State News

November 11, 2008

HB 1804 law foes are diverse

TULSA — Labor unions, the American Civil Liberties Union and advocates for immigrants are among a diverse coalition joining business groups in their court battle against parts of Oklahoma's House Bill 1804.

The coalition has submitted arguments to the federal appeals court in Denver against the employment-related parts of the law.

It joins the Tulsa, Oklahoma state and national chambers of commerce, which were successful in June in having a judge bar state officials from enforcing those parts.

The state officials have asked the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals to restore the provisions U.S. District Judge Robin Cauthron in Oklahoma City ruled in June are pre-empted by federal law.

Much of the opposition is focused on the part of HB 1804 that requires employers doing business with the state to use a voluntary federal worker verification system.

The opposition claims the electronic system is unreliable and that the law unfairly imposes penalties on employers failing to use the "E-Verify" program.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce says the diverse opposition is united by the belief that states should not be setting immigration policy, which should be left to the federal government. The national chamber took the lead in challenging the employment sections of the law.

"The emerging patchwork of conflicting state immigration laws is creating a national crisis," said Robin Conrad, executive director of the national chamber's public policy law firm, in a written statement.

The labor unions' opposition comes through a federation known as Change to Win, which includes the national and international unions of Teamsters, laborers, service employees, carpenters, farm workers and food and commercial workers.

Lawyers in the Oklahoma Attorney General's Office are defending the law.

Text Only
State News
Poll

Voters in the Edmond Public School District 2 will go to the polls from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Feb. 14 to decide between school board candidates Steve Roy and Kathleen Duncan. District 2 is roughly centered in northwest Edmond. Who will get your vote?

Steve Roy
Kathleen Duncan
     View Results